Do you place Martinez above Mayweather Jr right now on the P4P list?

:thumbsup wolf pac

 

based on your logic Pretty Boy Floyd is #1 P4P

dude aint lost since "96" & has dominated 40 opponents since :deal

 

not really. He didn't dominate Oscar.

 

youre out of you mind. martinez's resume doesnt justify him being in the top 5.

 

but donaires doesatsch

 

1 nonito donaire
2 sergio martinez

anyone who has the cherry pickers on top dont know **** about baaxing :deal

 

That's the issue, pac is too good for the guys at 147.

That's why I wanna see him try to unify at 154 where it'd be more competitive.

 

Cotto was the last significant win for Pac and that was over 2 years ago. Margo, I give him half credit just for teh fact that no Margo type of fighter beats a Pacquiao ever. Theres an expiration date for past performances and Pac has gotten credit for those already in the ATG ranking. But p4p needs to be current (1 - 2 years max)

I think beating someone like Sturm is enough to supplant Manny unless Pac fights and beat a Bradley or a Berto right after.

 

1. Pac
2. Martinez
3. Marquez
4. Donaire

Floyd is not on the list due to his inactivity.

 

Williams the the most feared fighter 2 years ago who defeated another most avoided fighter in margarito. Thats enough accomplishment for top 5.

 

Donaires skill level is out of this world and he now has a very good but not great resume to back it up.

 

1. Martinez
2. Wolak
3. Lee
4. Cotto
5. Donaire
6. Pacquiao

:deal

 

yes

 

right now my P4P list is:

1. PBF
2. Pacquiao
3. Vitali Klitschko
4. Martinez

Nobody cares about the rest. All 4 fighters have looked unbeatable lately.

I guess you could throw Nonito in at #5.

:good