Based purely on fights which occurred Jan 2000 - Dec 2009 1.Manny Pacquiao 2.Bernard Hopkins 3.Floyd Mayweather Jr 4.Marco Antonio Barrera 5.Juan Manuel Marquez 6.Erik Morales 7.Shane Mosley 8.Winky Wright 9.Jose Luis Castillo (I scored Mayweather 1 for JLC so that bumps him up into the top 10) 10.Joe Calzaghe There's no place for guys who only fought well for a couple of years or a few fights in the 00s, like Roy Jones, Lennox Lewis, Oscar De La Hoya, Tito Trinidad, James Toney, etc.
id have calzaghe higher than castillo. id have winky higher than mosley cos of the wins over shane and tito. top 6 is spot on
If you scored Castillo-Mayweather 1 for JLC, that puts him above someone with a resume as flimsy as Calzaghe's, and I had it to Castillo by 2. But I agree on Wink, he could easily be placed above SSM. I don't have a strong conviction either way.
Both Kilt brothers. Manny Mosely DLH Hopkins Lewis Mayweather Jr I suppose any of the middleweighr champions that swamp the title around like Pavlik, Taylor ete.
1.Manny Pacquiao 2.Bernard Hopkins 3.Floyd Mayweather Jr 4.Marco Antonio Barrera 5.Juan Manuel Marquez 6.Erik Morales 7.Winky Wright 8.Shane Mosley 9.Oscar De La Hoya 10.Jose Luis Castillo
Manny Pacquiao Floyd Mayweather Erik Morales Marco Antonio Barrera Bernard Hopkins Juan Manuel Marquez Oscar Delahoya Shane Mosely Joe Calzaghe Winky Wright Off the top of my head
1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Juan Manuel Marquez 3. James Toney 4. Chris Byrd 5. Ronald Wright 6. Glen Johnson 7. Nonito Donaire 8. Ponsaklek Wonjogkam 9. Carl Froch 10. Oscar Larios I might have very well did injustice with d below lightweight guys .
