ATG Ranking Pacquiao

well according to some Floyd hasn't done much and is barely top 50...i dont know how beating him gets you in the top 15 let alone 10.

 

you're very generous with your atg ranking for Tyson...
I will give Ali number 1 heavy, maybe 6 on my atg list.
Tyson, maybe number 10 heavy, barely makes my top 100 atg.

..as for Pacquiao, who knows where he'll be by retirement, looking damn good though.

 

I have him top 30, but he does have a thin resume-because he avoided fighters but talent wise i have mayweather in top 10/15

 

IMO Floyd is anywhere from 25 to 40.. :think Kind of hard to rank him right now, but he hth and talent wise there is no questioning his abilities... This would be a huge win.


Leonard wasnt considered an all time great when Duran beat him... HTH he was, that didnt take anything off Durans big win as Leonard went on to prove he was an elite atg also.

 

i've been saying this for months now. How does beating floyd who is not even a top 50 atg according to some push manny pac up 10-20 places on the atg list.

You can't have it both ways guys.

 

give me the fighters he avoided....i think i know who but i dont wanna jump the gun you may have a different list i've seen so many different combos of lists...lol

 

i agree H2H wise based off talent he can be rated pretty high...but we all know that thats not how most on here rate him...they include everything...that being said...i have yet to see many rank him past 30....so again i dont see how that pushes Pac to top 10 or 15 with a win.

You mentioned Leonard going on to prove greatness which is correct however i dont see Floyd doing anything bigger than beating maybe Martinez that would propell Floyd upwards and validate Pacs top 10 or 15 ranking.

 

Exactly:good

and your right some dont even have him top 50!

 

You guys arent understanding this whole atg ranking thing..... Anyone who cracks the top 100 is elite and iMO an atg, put it this way id rank Tszyu as a borderling top 100 guy, now if Pac beat a prime KT, would you not consider that a huge win that would add even more to his resume?

.. Another thing you talk like top 50 is chopped liver .. Besides only ones i know who have floyd outside their top 50 are cynical and probably dont even like Floyd...

 

...yea u do have a point here:good

 

cotto, margarito, prime mosley, ksyu at 140

 

If Pac beat Mayweather and Martinez at 160 .... Would you rate him number 1?

 

well Pac is already in the top20. Floyd is top40 and bigger than Pac so beating him convincingly puts Pac in the top 15

 

Top 5 if he did- 9 weight world champion

 

I don't think he will go up to that weight. He can't even make 150 at fight night.