Same thing happens most likely. Vic is good but some guys just cant deal with his style so he ends up looking deceptively good and people get the idea that he can do that with anyone. Donaire was the first to deal with Darchinyan's style and he ended the night big. Agebeko and Mares dealt with his style but didnt do as well as Darchinyan. Darchinyan has tons of fights in his career where he looks amazing and could beat anyone(Mijares, Perez, Kirliov) and then fights where he looks like **** or looks very beatable(Agbeko, Mares, Donaire, Gorres, Guerrero to a certain extent). But make no mistake Donaire will always have Darchinyan's number and is now even better then he was the first time they fought. Darchinyan is still there to be hit and Donaire would hit him with huge shots until he caughts him and he doesnt get up or until the ref or his corner seen enough.
Donaire would be the favorite, but never count Vic out, not at all, he is really good, if he is at his very best he is truly awesome!!!
I think Donaire deserves a bit more respect than you are giving him. I think he is pretty dopey to be honest, and I don't think much of his wife at all. But the guy is a freaking treat to watch in the ring. He may have earned the Nonentity tag because of his inaction after he beat Vic. But he is doing well now, and the tag doesn't fit anymore. You are 100% right that Vic would fight him at any time though. Donaire would KTFO Vic in the 5th round, and then Vic would want a third fight. Vic is one of the few people (apart from maybe his mother) who thinks he could win a rematch.
There are those in the 118, and then there is Donaire. He is simply operating on another level than those guys. Darchinyan vs. Montiel and I am sure it would be a competitive fight or Darchinyan vs. Agbeko., But Donaire against any of those fight and it would not be competitive. Donaire is simply a class above theose guys. Let's see - height, power on both hands, speed, timing, ring intelligence, and he even kjnows how to use his height.
Donaire is HUGE compared to Vic. And remember Vic was doign what Vic does when he got caught by Donaire. Vic would have to pull a Christian M. performance again to beat Donaire. BUT I dont see this fight happening due to weight.
It would be a brutal Roy Jones vs Montell Griffin style first round KO. I don't even think the fight is worth considering, but if Vic really wants to get knocked into retirement by Donaire then feed him to Donaire. Let Donaire knock him out in spectacular fashion on Shobox. And once Donaire is finished with him Donaire should take on someone on his level like Rigondeux or Gamboa.
He should take the Mando to keep busy and make some extra money. He will need to stay sharp if hes going to fight Gambao or Rigondeux next.
Donaire should take the fight, it's a big money fight and it will make him look good and probably result in spectacular KO.
Donaire can move up in weight and challenge Gamboa or Rigondeux. Bigger fighters, tougher fights, more money.
You're ****ing funny. Donaire is the real deal. As much as I like Vic, Nonito eats him for breakfast.