Trinidad vs. Toney @ 160. At their best, who wins?

I was watching some old Trinidad fights last night on youtube and I couldn't help but think of some fantasy matchups. They are both in my top 5 for all time favorite so I'm not sure who I would pick but I might lean for Toney.

What do you all think? How would this play out to you?

Toney's defense and counter punching or Tito's aggression and power shots?

 

Toney schools the **** out of him.

 

Toney, easily. Trinidad was a puncher, he won't beat a superior boxer in his prime. The only two boxers Trinidad faced at 160 completely dominated him. De La Hoya even outboxed his ass(DLH would've won had he fought down the stretch). This is a terrible matchup for Tito. My prediciton, one sided beat down in favor of Toney.

 

Come on....Trinidad doesn't even have a punchers chance in this one, much less a chance in a straight up match up.

 

Toney would stop him in about 6 rounds IMHO.

 

Toney would probably ko him in the 8 round

 

Both at their best I like Toney.

 

Was this guys serious with this matchup:?

 

Toney by wide UD or late stoppage

 

Toney would win a wide decision or even stop him late. Toney would be much bigger and Tito's greatest strength, his punching power wouldn't be enough to hurt Toney.

 

Toney easily. Btw? Trinidad's best is at 47 so it's a rather poor comparison.

 

Toney of course. No disrespect to Tito though. He was a badass mofo at 147.

 

Toney is too damn big for tito..

 

Trinidad has no chance. Toney by wide UD.

 

Toney by UD or even late TKO.