Who gets the most victories out of these out of these 4?

Hoya, winky, hearns, norris. Imagine these 4 all fight each other at lmw.

Who picks up the most victories iyo? And why?

 

Hearns 3-0
Winky 2-1
Norris 1-2
DLH 0-3 (Him and Norris would be close, I could actually go either way on that one.)

 

Hearns easy.
Simply because he only struggled with brawlers and none of these men are that.
Oscar and Norris would have the power to hurt him but not beat him. Winky and Oscar i can envision maybe lasting the distance with their toughness and know how. Norris wouldn't see the fifth.
But none of them would have enough in their make up to beat him.
Tommy is too complete and powerful for all three.

 

Hoya 3-0
Hearns 2-1
Winky 1-2
Norris 0-3

 

Oscar loses to all three.

The other three would be very closely matched in each fight, but I'd back Hearns to emerge as the winner overall.

 

R U a big Hoya fan??? I like him and find him underappreciated, but that is to be excpected. I just don't see how his 3-1 real life record pre 04, at 154 give an indication that he would beat these guys??? He was just ahead on the cards vs vargas (behind on one), lost to Mosley...I don't see how victories over Javiar and Campas and even Vargas give an indication that at 154 Oscar would be able to hang with the elite of the division???

Just my take.

 

Hearns 3-0
Winky 2-1
ODLH 1-2
Norris 0-3

 

:good My choice as well.

 

Hearns beats all of them!!

Norris can't handle the hitmans punch
Hearns can box with Winky and Winky won't have enough to keep Tommy off..
DLH might give Tommy some issues for a bit, but Hearns still beats him..

Hearns 3-0
Norris 2-1
Winky + DLH 1-2 they are pretty even for me maybe a 1-1-1 then :good

 

Hearns easily 3-0

Oscar 0-3

Winky 1-2

Norris 2-1


Yep i'm goin with terry Norris to beat Winky.

 

Hearns vs DLH would be for young teen mex-american girls what Hearns vs Duran was to Duranimal.

 

/thread

 

No I'm not really a fan of any boxer apart from frank bruno haha.

I though hoya beat mosley in the rematch. His body of work over all is quite impressive imo, it's just a shame about his inactivity.

But his skillset carried well through the weights and his combo punching is definitely better than vargas which is why I have him beating winky.

He had a tremendous jab which I think would offset norris enough and he'd catch him with a big hook eventually.

And hearns, yeah my pick is ridiculous but I just love the underdog. I think hoya has a good enough frame and chin to stand toe to toe with hearns for a few rounds, I think he certainly has the power to end hearns. I'd have to favour hearns to beat him but I wouldn't be surprised if the golden boy pulled it off.

I do think he's underrated but soon people will appreciate how much of a warrior he was and there is an argument that shane was the first to beat him. I think he lost to pea, shane, sturm, hopkins, floyd, pac and he beat tito, shane, quartey. Such a shame he didn't get the winky fight.

 

I think Tommy beats them all.

I think Hoya struggles with both Wright and Norris, but I can see him beating both, as well. He was quite good, and could still dig pretty hard at 154.

Winky would beat Norris, and could beat Oscar. Too inactive to beat Hearns, but he puts up the best fight and maybe makes it the distance.

Norris struggles in every match here. I give him the best shot against Oscar, because it would likely end up a firefight with Norris' dervish against Oscar's carpet bombing. Thats a fight Norris could win. I just don't think he would, I tend to favor the better boxer in these fights. Norris gets picked off by Wright when he can't overwhelm him, and fails to make it out of the 4th against Hearns.

 

Hearns 3 wins 3 KOs