If Khan Beats Zab Judah Should He Be Number #1 140lber?

It'd make him and bradley equal IMO. He won't be number 1 until he beats bradley.

 

Please don't use Barrera as a victory that has merit.

 

At Malignaggi over Witter. The comment of somebody with little idea of the context of that Witter victory at the time and is basing it off Boxrec and Witter's recent form. Thats ludicrous. Witter was a strong favorite over the unknown Bradley at the time, was WBC champion, and was at home. I know its you as well Taco Bill, buffoon.

 

I have it him at number 1 already. Think he beats Bradley on a wide UD everytime.

 

I'd put him number 1 if he beats Judah, He can't go number 1 just by beating Bradley if Bradley won't fight him!

 

No, Judah is cooked.

 

The win over Witter by the inexperienced Bradley who'd never fought anywhere near that level before was superior.

The home cooking from the one judge was ridiculous.

 

Its an interesting question but i dont see it tbh !!! , Judah as we all know is a front runner and has a tendancy to fade in fights , his skills are exeptional but a win over Zab does not have Khan leapfrog Bradley IMHO !!!

Bradley has beaten two of the divisions top contenders while they were unbeaten , and in Alexander a genuine world champion , for me Khan is ranked #3 behind Bradley and Alexander and i say that because his career best win @140 was a threadbare win over Maidana who was practically schooled by Morales and looked like **** against Corley .

Alexander's KO victory over Urango and his well contested decision over Kotelnik IMO puts him ahead of Khan who's one defeat is against a very limited nobody in Prescott , pitted against Alexanders 1 defeat who is Tim Bradley !!!

Khan beats Judah and he takes a step towards Tim Bradley but does not surpass him

 

**** off Win

Prescott means little when comparing 140 standings as well IMO :good

 

Ive seen some of your Alexander Kotelnik asessments and have swiftly moved on with a slight smile on my face as i know you think he lost that fight , me on the other hand i think he won a " closely contested decision " , thats just the way i seen the fight . Hotly debatable as it is its my asessment

Agree'd but ................ compare best wins , compare defeats IMHO Alexander comes out on top , maybe that will be confirmed if / when he beats Matthyse , and Khan Judah is still in the pre tense , Khan is not all that , he struggled to land a meaningfull shot on Paul McCloskey in the first 4 rounds , and he's the #1 LWW in the world ??:huh , i personally dont think so , sorry mate veared off topic there , but for now ill stand by what i say 1) TB , 2) DA , 3) AK , is as i see it right now today

Edit : id be shocked if Khan beats Judah .................