Broener by decision, "The problem" has the reach advantage and just as much technical ability, IMHO, speed (slgt adv. to Camacho) and power at the weight.
I take it you've never seen the 130 Camacho..... SLIGHT speed adv to Camacho? Camacho @ 130 had the fastest hands of anybody in history not named Roy Jones. And Broner isnt more powerful either. Prime Camacho was another level all together than the Floyd wannabe. Camacho would NOT have needed a gift decision over Ponce De LeBum.
I've seen him at 130, and yes I say slight advantage over Broener because I rate Broener's speed very highly myself. Broner carries a power advantage in my mind. You can dislike Broener all you want, doesn't phase me, I think Broener could get a points decision over Camacho.
Actually I dont dislike Broner at all, although he IS a shameless Floyd wannabe. And if you think Broner's handspeed is anywhere NEAR young Camacho's, I honestly think you need your eyes checked. Prime Camacho would give FLOYD a tough fight at 130. He'd beat the **** outta Broner.
I think you need to take the rose tinted glasses off and be objective. Look at his fights and time the punches in his fights to Broener's punches and you don't get much of a drop off, even though I feel Broener is a step slower in the speed dept, but has a touch more in the power dept.