I think Calzaghe should probably be above Toney, but this is bad reasoning. Toney has lost 6 times in 80 fights, Calzaghe being undefeat in 46 is a poor reason to rank him higher.
Being undefeated isn't everything. Toney was a three weight world champion while Calzaghe was only a one weight world champion. Does that not count for anything?
Good question Hopkins Jones Calzaghe Toney And it didn't have to be that way for James. He had all the talent in the world. It's just the discipline he lacked.
1. Roy 2. Calzaghe (in my view, beat the better competition and never lost) 3. Hopkins (due to the above) 4. Toney. Over rated, guy was a great fighter who squandered his talents, not quite as badly as Judah but on the same page.
Fail. Robinson lost consistently at the end of his career. Ali lost to the likes of Spinks and Berbick at the end of his.
Joe is a 2 weight champion. Joe was the undisputed champion at SMW and had the WBO, WBC, WBA, and IBF belts. Had the most defences at SMW with 21 to be exact. Move up too LHW in he first fight at 175 and beats the Lineal champ Bhop. Than he beats Roy jones. Plus Toney was striped of his hw belt cause he did steriods.