What´s your, let´s say Top 20 in no order? Here´s mine: Muhammad Ali Marvin Hagler George Chuvalo Rocky Marciano Harry Greb Jake LaMotta Tony Canzoneri James Toney Duilio Loi Panama Al Brown Charles Burley Vito Antuofermo Sam Langford Oliver McCall Randall Tex Cobb Mike Gibbons Freddie Miller Dave Shade Jack Britton Kid Gavilan Perhaps I forgot someone...
Fine choices. I'd throw Jim Jeffries into the mix. From the modern bunch Calzaghe deserves a mention.
Ray Mercer. In his prime the guy had a rock solid jaw. Watch him take flush bombs from Cooper, Morrison, and Lewis.
Thanks. I thaught about both. But Jeffries faced almost only smaller men, that´s why I didn´t mention him in a p4p- list, where other fighters fought some weight classes above their natural weight and showed their iron chin, and with Calzaghe, well, if I would have made a Top 25-list, we would be in...
Tier 1 Marvin Hagler Jake LaMotta Jose Napoles Tier 2 Kid Gavilan Carlos Monzon Tony Canzoneri Tier 3 Ray Robinson Ray Leonard Muhammad Ali Tier 4 Emile Griffith Ike Williams Alexis Arguello Tier 5 Willie Pep Joe Louis Harold Johnson Those would be my above average ratings. As you can see, there are very fine lines between separations.
Good work Manassa, I agre with Moore's high placing. Louis is to high though. What's your thinking there? Why is his chin better than, say, Mike Tyson's?
Ah, but Tyson's chin is better than Louis' I just removed Moore in place of Pep, although Moore stays in that tier. I believe Louis was quite a durable fighter - more than his knockdown record would imply, at least. He was almost always up within a couple of seconds, and it took a hell of a battering for Schmeling & Marciano to take him out.
I would think so, after 100+ fights and after reigning as middleweight champion for years and never having been stopped. That's tier one in my opinion.
Not quite, a step below. Monzon was knocked down four times in his career to our knowledge and had his brains scrambled by a wicked Briscoe right - which is far more than Hagler had done to him. Monzon was tough as old boots and is only a hair behind, but a hair behind he is. You can argue that Napoles was floored three times in his career and was stopped - but he demonstrated an immense capacity for taking punishment in that loss to Monzon.