Oscar by decision. If Tito couldnt put Reid away, I cant see Oscar doing it, but however Oscar still wins. Just based on him having superior skill and experience. Reid was talented as hell, but his actual skill left alot to be desired, and his ring intelligence was severly lacking. He WOULD give Oscar trouble though. Oscar has never done well against fast guys, and Reid had faster hands than Oscar and was a bigger man. But he simply lacked the skills and brains to beat Oscar.
but people gotta remember oscar had slightly under the fire power of tito ..only comming at you 90 mph more quicker then tito could throw i could see oscar stopping reid late
Actually at 154 Oscar wasnt THAT much quicker than Tito at all. Oscar's handspeed declined after he moved up from 147, and Tito's hands were VERY quick at 154. And Oscar didnt just have "slightly" less firepower. Tito was a bigger puncher than Oscar period! And by a considerable margin.
yeah the lack of discipline being that reid chose to go to war at times instead of boxing and useing his right hand