So hard to place Frasier because of the defeat to big George Foreman. This is what I really enjoy with Jo - you just don't know where to put him. I genuinely think that he would take out Mike Tyson with a KO later on. I think that Larry Holmes and Lennox Lewis would have been more difficult for Frasier, but they'd probably find out about themselves too. No question, Jo is not a p4p great, not the best heavy that ever took the title, but he was bloody good, and for me he's always going to be in my top ten.
Prime Frazier would be a tough night for just about anyone. You either had to outbox him and stay away or hit hard enough to back him up and stop him. There didn't seem too be much middle ground in regards to fighting him. Like some earlier posts I would favor some hw's against him but it wouldn't be a cinch in my opinion. Makes me think of why Apollo Creeds trainer told Apollo not to fight Rocky a second time..."I saw you beat that man like I never saw a man get beat, and the man kept coming after you!" That sums up a fight with a prime Frazier. Like my Father used to say when I would threaten to kick his ass (albeit jokingly), "Bring your lunch cuz it's gonna take you all day".
i agree vic. but as fond as i am on frazier there are quit a few man i see beating frazier. i will list those wich i think. foreman, liston, dempsey, louis, holmes, tyson, max baer, riddick bowe
I think that he would do better against the pure boxers than pretty much anybody else. I also think that people are a bit too quick to dismiss him against the punchers, based on the Foreman fight. In all, I think he is getting under rated head to head at the moment.
Against the top 10 best h2h - He'd lose to Foreman, Ali, Lewis, Tyson, Louis, Holmes IMO Think he and Holy are pretty even. Think he beats Dempsey, Norton, Tunney, Johnson
71 Frazier does pretty good....But 1969 Frazier just might be the best h2h HW that ever lived. I would favor Foreman/Liston the beat him and call Marciano, Louis, Holyfield even pick em's...Other than that I feel comfortable w/ Joe's chance against anyone else. Joe is underrated so quite a few (especially delusional Tyson huggers) will not favor him over very many.
I agree except I think Frazier would beat Holmes at their respective peaks. Joe would have a pretty decent shot against Joe Louis as well.
I disagree that better technicians would beat Joe. I think Holmes, who is a fearsome head-to-head heavyweight, would be beat prime for prime. He is a specialist pur-sang -- going forward and giving pressure is his sole game against ATG elite competition. This is both a strength and a weakness. Against punchers, it would always come down to a shootout, but even there, he has amazing determination, getting to the last round in the FOTC past-prime and getting up six times against Foreman. You aren't sparking the man with a single shot -- he is going to fight his own body for the opportunity to stay in there and give you hell. Men like Gene Tunney, Holmes, Holyfield, Jack Johnson would be the biggest underdogs imo. Agains the bigger punchers, he'd win some and lose some. Who wouldn't.