Round 1 Who wins in their respective primes? Rocky Marcinano vs Prime Vitli Klitschko Hagler vs Hopkins Tommy Hearns vs Paul Williams Duran vs Cotto Willie pep vs Floyd Jr. Vote and Discuss each fight!
No one is discussing. According to the poll so far the only fight is not a mismatch is hagler vs bhop.
Rocky Marcinano vs Prime Vitli Klitschko = Klit, just far far to big. Hagler vs Hopkins = Hopkins I feel bit to smart and would tie him up, may be boring Tommy Hearns vs Paul Williams = Hearns by KO Duran vs Cotto = Duran by KO Willie pep vs Floyd Jr. = Floyd UD Even between modern and Classic for me
The only fair matchup on the list Hagler vs Hopkins. I feel that Hagler would just outwork and overwhelm Hopkins. Surprisingly, Hagler would get the better of the clinches, which Bernard would instigate. I don't see Hopkins gaining Haglers repect with his punches, his chin was granite. Hagler close UD Duran mops the ring with Cotto. Williams gets a concussion in 4 rds max Klitschko far too big and strong for Marciano Floyd too big and fast for Pep, whose only chance to win would have to overly aggressive which he wouldn't. Floyd would be accurate with his punches as usually and may choose to chase him down and possibly stop him late.
Pep was a featherweight, hardly fair to put him in against Floyd. I didn't vote on it. Vitali too big for Marciano. I voted Hagler against Hopkins but it could go either way. Hearns and Duran easy.