Primes: Floyd/Oscar/Shane

Who Was the best?
IMO, Oscar was.

 

Oscar.

 

Oscar
Mayweather
Mosley

 

1. Floyd
2. Oscar
3. Shane

 

1)Oscar
2)Floyd - close second
3)Mosley - just misses out

 

1.PBF
2.Shane tie
2.Oscar
PBF will have the best ATG rating of the 3.:deal

 

PBF's ring IQ has always been better than Oscar's prime for prime.:deal

 

At 147, Oscar and Shane.

P4P, I'll take Floyd just above Oscar for now. Shane lagging behind despite the win over Oscar.

 

Prime for Prime:
01. Oscar De La Hoya (Should be self explanatory)
02. Shane Mosley (Was so quick and powerful back in the day not to mention an excellent KO ratio)
03. Floyd Mayweather (High In-Ring IQ.. Just hasn't done enough IMO to be ranked better than DLH or Mosley prime for prime..)

 

What has Mosley except beating Oscar 2x he hasn't looked like the same fighter since he left 135. His career isn't better than PBF's who is already arguably a top 30 ATG. Oscar fought big names but lost and got gifts in others he shouldn't get credit for losing not to mention he's 0-1 against PBF about to be 0-2 and 0-2 against Mosley as well. This isn't a popularity contest if that's the case he wins but overall PBF is the superior boxer of the 3 and has had a better career.

 

quite a hard one im giving floyd the benefit of the doubt and puting him top with oscar second and shane third.

floyd
oscar
ssm

 

Talking prime for prime here.. Mosley is no where near is prime now and I can't see Mayweather beating Oscar in his prime.. As far as better careers, Floyd may be undefeated but Oscar fought the likes of Trinidad, Hopkins, Vargas, JCC, Whitaker, & Camacho.. This is just my opinion here.. My opinion means nothing if you don't want it to..

 

Mosley