Anyone interested. Please ranks these fighters by one punch punching power. Pound for pound. Joe Louis Archie Moore Jimmy Wilde Sandy Saddler Rocky Marciano Bob Foster Thomas Hearns Jack Dempsey Wilfredo Gomez Stanley Ketchel Mike Tyson Joe Frazier Felix Trinidad. Thanks, Keith
P4P is always tough to gauge. I don't know how any can do with that list accurately. They could try but it's tough to say. I would be interested to see some of the results.
Jimmy Wilde Thomas Hearns Bob Foster Stanley Ketchell Joe Louis Felix Trinidad Sandy Saddler Rocky Marciano Archie Moore Mike Tyson Wilfredo Gomez Jack Dempsey Joe Frazier
I know it's real hard. That's why I'm asking for help. I'm not trying to open this up for debate reasons, I am expressly interested in everyones opinions, as I have them all on or around the level. Thanks to everyone who attempts. Keith
One punch power with Louis over Marciano? I can't agree with that. And P4P even distorts that even more. That's generous for Foster, too. That seems harsh on Dempsey. At least you had the guts to try. Can't knock that since I avoided doing so .
you could be right with Louis and Marciano but i do think Louis is the harder hitter. Marciano is more of an accumlative puncher whereas i think Louis is more a combination puncher. Foster was a huge hitter, freaky hitter his power was scary yeh it is hard to do and nobody will get it 100% right its all opinion
You aren't in the only boat with feeling Louis hit harder than Marciano. With all the one punch knockouts Marciano had I think it's people getting confused with some of the title defenses where he was a bit more of a swarmer than the 1 punch KO artist. Louis on the other had is the better puncher. But in terms of power, don't think so, especially when it's P4P. That's just my 2 cents.
Generally the lighter guys are always going to generate more power P4P. I'll get back to you. This will require much thought.
Rough guide. 1Ketchel 2 Foster 3 Hearns 4 Marciano 5 Louis 6Wilde 7 Moore 8 Dempsey 9 Tyson 10 Tyson 11 Trinidad 13 Saddler
Thomas Hearns Wilfredo Gomez Bob Foster Stanley Ketchel Jimmy Wilde Sandy Saddler Felix Trinidad Jack Dempsey Mike Tyson Rocky Marciano Joe Frazier Archie Moore Joe Louis I hate my list so I won't mind if people critizise it badly. I'm basically a heavyweights fan, so my knowledge of other divisions is limited.
So far Foster and Hearns are getting consistently high rankings. Thanks everyone so far. I would like to get maybe two more opinions. Thanks, Keith