Records

great work

 

if it's true - then sorry and you're really fine.
also , i didn't consider just you when i wrote that.
there are also other things than OCD that can lead people to over-do such things.

 

Maxie won 106

106-39-26 (1 NC) = 172

 

Yeah I saw that.

I suppose the end result of this thread will be a lot of suggestion and debate regarding the substance of the numbers, then some toss-ups, and maybe some revisions of pound-for-pound lists. Rosenbloom, for one, is a fighter who probably wouldn't appear in many top fifty lists - but he probably deserves it. Nope, he hasn't got the consistency of Ray Robinson but the sheer ability of him to overcome so many tough opponents must propell him into the upper echelons.

 

Pedro Montanez is up, plus a few changes.

 

Manassa, seriously interesting thread mate :good

 

Jack Kid Berg would be quite impressive looking at Montanez.

 

Sonny Liston will be up in a sec.

 

Kid Chocolate's done.

 

John Henry Lewis is up, not a bad one.

 

Actually comparing the two, Greb's resume is far superior to Langford's. Langford was mostly fighting the same fighters over and over and over again, whereas Greb had a lot more variety.

 

I thought that. I'd rather have fought fifty elite fighters than fight ten of them five times each.

 

Jose Napoles is done, had to put it in the second post as the first one got too long.

 

You can add:

Henry Clark
Amos Johnson
Roger Rischer
Elmer Rush

 

You can also add:

Frankie Kid Anselm
Phil Baker
Vic Burrone (x3)
Fillo Echeverria,
Charley Gomer
Jackie Johnston
Eddie O’Dowd (x2)
Emil Paluso (x2)
Al Ridgeway
Joey Ross
Harry Sankey
Al Singer
Steve Smith (x6)