Everyone gon put Roy jones lol but if like to know what other boxers people will put on their list. Edit: I'm talking about of all time. Not just current fighters
Ray Robinson has to be at or near the top. If you're talking about the best athletes currently in the sport though... Pacquaio Martinez Mayweather Wladimir Stevenson and Rigo seem to be pretty good athletes too, but it's very difficult to define exactly what you mean. The most explosive guys in the sport seem to be Judah, Martinez and Pacquaio though. However, Martinez like Judah, is on the decline.
how do you distinguish between an overall most athletic list and a p4p? need to break it up into different areas of athleticism to even have a conversation about it.
Does the fact that he is slowfooted, slowhanded, awkward and somewhat uncoordinated compared to most of his opposition not mitigate that a bit? When I hear the word athletic, I don't necessarily think of stamina and physical strength. Which I'm sure Froch has plenty of, but he was bullied around the ring by Andre Ward quite a bit. Ali, SRL, Meldrick Taylor, Pacquiao, Roy Jones, Sergio Martinez, guys like that is who I think of.
Athleticism is rather ambiguous. Are we talking physique, stamina, fleetness of foot or hand, recovery ability, power, reflexes, etc. I'm going to assume you mean fleetness of hand and foot, and or reflexes. These athletic attributes tend to have an aesthetically pleasing attribute. Rigondeaux Floyd Lomachenko Martinez Pacquaio Khan Crawford Garcia Judah Stevenson no particular order