What sixth round did you give him, then? A case could be made for Alexander in the 1st through 3rd, and the 5th (I gave him all four). He clearly won the 9th. Of the remaining five rounds - 4, 6, 7, 8 and 10 there is not one in which you can make a legitimate case for Alexander. I too watched it a few times and only affirmed this. Without one of those rounds, he can not have won.