Anyone else score it a shut out?

Same.

Even the few rounds where Haye had some success and landed the bigger shots, I still had those for Wlad for his consistent scoring with the jab and overall ring generalship.

Just landing a few bombs in a round where your opponent is manipulating you around the ring with his feet and peppering you with his jab is not enough to win them in my eyes.

 

I had it 118-108.

I don't know what the one guy was thinking (116-110)?

 

Yup. You could have been generous and given Haye round 3, and the round where Wlad had a point deducted. But that's it. Haye did not 'win' a single round.

 

the 3rd round was hayes
you cant just pepper with a few little jabs and win a round with just ring generalship

 

Same as you McGrain, Wlad took every round.

Haye almost took round 3, but not on my card.

 

there were 2 rds the 3rd and the last rd that Haye landed a clean punch so I generously gave them to him but I still think he lost the last rd and the other could have gone to Vlad but you try to be fair. I tend to favor the aggressor so a shut-out would not be unreasonable...Haye fought a survivor fight and his right toe was sore from back-peddling and side-winding...He want to land one shot and go home but ran for the most part after he found Vlad hard to hit and when he did land Vlad took it well and went right back at him.

 

I had him winning 3 rounds at a push, some rounds quite close but a clear win for Wlad.

 

Yeah, I had it the same. I gave Haye the 3rd and every other round to Wlad with the point deuction round being 9-9.

 

I had it every round to WK, one of which was 10-8.

 

Sky commentators mentioned at about rd 10 that Foreman had it level.

 

I gave Haye 3 rounds. I think that he had some success early in the fight.

 

Of course you can.

If one fighter is the aggressor, consistenly landing the jab, controlling the distance, cutting the ring down, manipulating his opponent's position with his footwork and for the most part making them miss and fall short with punches - they don't lose the round just because they're hit with 3-4 solid shots.

 

I gave Haye 2 rounds. Only 1 was legit due to the false point deduction

 

i was unsure of 2 rounds but a shutout wouldnt be unfair becuase wlad probably landed as many punches in haye's better rounds