Who Is You P4P #1 If Floyd Beats Oscar and Pac/Calzaghe Are Also Impressive?

Marco was not shot.

oscar is shot.

hatton wasnt even in pbf league

if you are going by having a unblemish record sven ottke is the best, and joan guzman should be right outside pbf doorstep for the spot.

floyd jr is number 3 in my book.

I got either pacquiao or calzaghe taking the number 1 spot depending on there year.

Floyd jr is a disgrace, All he cares for his money.

ALI never questioned anyone he said lets fight boy! lets fight!

thats why he and sugar ray robinsion are legends.

floyd jr will never be a legend unless he fights cotto, williams, cintron, and margarito he would need to fight those guys and in in devastating fashion.

beating a blown up hatton aint ****.

it was an entertaining fight but it is not enough to cement a legacy.

Calzaghe has so many defenses so he will secure his and he reigned supreme for so long.

pacquiao if he beats jmm will secure his and then if he gets a title at 135 and 140 his legacy shits on floyd jr.

 

atsch in all honesty MAB has been past it since the Juarez fight...hatton wasnt in PBF league? well to bad who's fault is that?

******* i dont go by the 0 pbf has on his record i go by body of work over a whole career. you got joe ahead of pbf based on what? beating manfredo and kessler...please dont tell me that's better than beating dlh at 54 and p4p top 10 hatton.......


how dare you mention joe's defenses and say he has secured his legacy because of them.....who the **** was he defending against?

what did pac do in 07?


like i said until pbf loses he stays #1

he's already cemented his legacy
6 titles in 5 different weight classes 3 lineal titles


hernandez,manfredy,corrales,castillo(2x) judah,baldomir,DLH and Hatton

 

What if Foyd dosen't fight this year, as he stated was his intention? With that logic VK is still the Hw champ!

 

he is fighting though

 

Boxing or MMA?

 

they say he's fighting dlh in sept

 

just for that he shoudl get his spot taken.

 

oh who has floyd jr fought shot oscar, and hatton?

dont forget that time when floyd jr pot shot his way to victory and people walked out against baldo lol what a challenge! the guy is slow as a snail with many losses.

also there was a point when he foguht shambra mitchell, demarcus corely,henry bruseles, arturo gatti who are not even top guys.

a guy of floyd jr caliber shouldnt even be taking fights like that.

 

M$M is P4P

 

The fights not needed. The first fight wasn't great. Reminds me of a "get-by" fight on FNF's when a fighter dosen't look great but wins. He realizes, "Hey, I didn't look great tonight but I need to progress in my career". The crappy fights forgotten and the fighter goes on to bigger and better things.

I Know from a money stand point ODLH is the biggest thing he can get. However, not even close to the best competition. Hey, i'd much rather see him fight Hatton.

He needs to fight Cotto.

 

He will be p4p #1 until he lose. Simple really as Oscar is not as shot as most people say he is. He is 34 and has not taken any big punishment in his career and the fact that he would still whup most of the WW.

 

PBF defeating DLH or not should not be a factor in the P4P ratings.

It's uneventful fight for PBF . . . period. :yep

 

by who?

 

atsch dlh is not shot.....hatton was top 10 p4p...yea pbf potshotted baldomir so what.....baldomir was undisputed WW champ....the brusles and corley fights were WBC title eliminators that he had to fight...he wanted to beat gatti then fight the winner of tszyu hatton...hatton declined the fight....mitchell was his first fight at WW....gatti rated #2 jrww and was WBC champ.....

 

Thats the point though. Why doesn't he take on the other WW's that are clearly better than DLH???