Which fight was closer?

Mayweather Castillo 115-113
Pacquiao Marquez II 114-113

 

both could have gone eitherway but castillo makes a better case than jmm

 

Pacquiao-Marquez II probably could have gone either way. Castillo-Mayweather I was a Castillo win.

 

Pacquiao-JMM II.

I had an easier time scoring Mayweather-Castillo I (which I gave to Castillo)

 

this is what i meant and i had my vote mixed up

 

One close round either way and both fights can change victors. I scored both for the "loser."

 

I thought Mayweather beat Castillo but it's a 50/50 with PAC JMM 2 I tend to score it differently each time I watch it.

 

With the castillo fight it depends on how you score fights and how much of HBO's commentary you were listening to

 

This is exactly how i feel :good

 

I say Pac-JMM II because not only was the score close to even, many rounds themselves were close to even as well.

 

this...^

 

Mayweather-Castillo I. Floyd won a close fight that could've gone either way, I had it for JLC by a point. Marquez won 8 rounds as was robbed. The decisive majority of all experts, fighters and writers had JMM winning. The fight was close in a sense, close but clear for the Mexican.

 

PBF vs Castillo I.

 

I thought Marquez edged Pacquiao, HBO commentary was leading people to believe that Pacquiao was winning. The best I can give Pac is a draw.

I thought Joy won the Castillo fight by 1 or 2 points, and I could also see a Castillo victory by 1 or 2 points.

So I'd say that the Mayweather-Castillo fight was a closer fight than Pac-Marquez II, however I felt the wrong man won the latter.