Rate Marcos Maidana skills out of 10

Power 9
Speed 5
Offence 8
Defence 6
Heart 8.5
Chin 7

overall 7.5

 

Power 8/10
Speed 5/10
Offence 7/10
Defence 4/10
Heart 10/10
Chin 7/10
Recuperating ability 10/10

Overall 7/10

 

power 8/10
speed 3/10
offence 5/10
defence 3/10
heart 9/10
chin 7/10

overall 5-6/10

 

you should make it clear your poll is overall ability not skill

 

Power - 8
Speed - 6
Offense - 7
Defense - 5
Heart - 9
Chin - 6/7

Overall - 6.5-7

 

You seriously believe Maidana would be solid top 3 at 140lbs if his overall ability was a mere 5? Never been stopped with 85%? k.o. record....

 

I think he's more aggessive than Manny Pacquiao.

 

About 6 I guess

 

I'd say he's about a 7. Someone like khan is a solid 8 where the p4p guys are a 9.

 

Out of interest, how would you score the guy in your avatar?

 

Power 8
Speed 6
Offence 7
Defence 5
Heart 9
Chin 8

overall 7.2

 

Yep, imo it's an average division and the attributes i scored him high on (power heart and chin) ensure that he is a dangerous prospect at world level. For me technically he is shite but due to his power heart and chin he is above average which his top three ranking in a mediocre division reflects. He wont be the first or the last big punching hardman that has been a top 3 contender whilst severely lacking in other departments.

 

Power 9
Speed 7
Offence 8
Defence 6
Heart 9
Chin 8

overall 7

 

I think you scored him too low on speed, should be a 5 and offense a 7, the guy only fights one way, pure seek & destroy. His defense is should be higher aswell, a 4. Heck I'd even give Carl a 4 for defense and he blocks punches using his face....