zero loss can be taken away anytime - that is what mayweather is doing right now, cherry picking fights in order to avoid his zero to be taken. "0" loss- marciano, calzaghe, floyd etc.
Cotto was weightdrained...but I always gave Pac credit for Cotto...Pac destroyed him and he was younger than Pac I think...to me, what it all boils down to is they are just about equal in different ways
Floyd's 0 is also suspect since he didn't fight Margo and/or Cotto and moreso if he doesn't go on and fight Pac. There's also that questionable win over Castillo.
Pac 8th and Floyd 0 are less relevant than them just fighting each other. Both will finish outside of top 20 ATG unlike fighters like Duran and SRL that fought each other and build their legacies
Pacs accomplishments and far outweigh mayweather. mayweather needs to hold on to that 0 because that is his best claim to fame.
Ricardo Lopez's 51-0 > Marciano, Calzaghe, Floyd Pac's 7th world better accomplishment than Floyd's 0 Plus pac has, prime Barrera, Prime Marquez, and close to prime Morales in his resume, all in their adequate weight divisions. No fighter in Floyd's resume comes close to any one of those 3.
Neither accomplishment matters that much; when bringing both overall careers into sharp relief they're just two among many accomplishments for both. Not the biggest, just among many big ones.
Pacquiaos 8 is complete bs. In fact any title is bs unless you are widely considered the best in the division.
I agree with you about his welterweight title. It's totally legit and he's continued to defend it. I was just answering the question the way it was stated - Mayweather's 0 (which is his entire career) or Pacquiao's 8th title (which was 1 fight in his career against Margarito that should not have been a world title fight).
Floyd's 0 is bull****. The only reason he was undefeated back in the day was because he was with arum and arum protected him.
Mayweather got his "0" by beat solid to outstanding oppnoents. Pacquiao got his "8" by fighting less than the best at miulpited weights to binifet him. In otherwords Mayweather has gotten his "0" the honest way. Pacquiao can not say the same about his "8".
There is no doubt Pac is a far better ATG but Margarito was not better than Ortiz or Mosley. Margarito had 1 win in two years vs a nobody and looked terrible against him.
Pacquiao's 8 titles of course... Void has ducked all the good welters and he has fooled the world into thinking that he's a special fighter! He's not, he is a fraud!