It's no coincidence that Floyd didn't participate when the welterweight division was stacked, deep with talent, and the best in boxing. Reporter: Why now? Why come back? Why did you leave anyway? Mayweather: I stayed out of the sport for my HEALTH, both mentally and physically. I stay fresh this way. :hi:
That's really a shitty argument. I don't understand how people think the WW Fighters like Cotto and Margarito, hell even Paul Williams were the fighters at WW at the time were that BADDASS enough to beat Floyd. I just don't get that argument.
Whether they were badass to beat him or not isn't the point, the point is that he didn't fight them at the time.
Its not that those guys were definite badasses to beat Floyd. Its just that the welterweight division, at the time, was stacked with really good fighters fighting each other. The least youd expect, is for the most talented and skilled one out of all of them, to be part of it. When history looks back at that 2007-2009 period, itll see the following memorable welterweight fights involving the top welterweight fighters.... - Williams vs Marg - Mosley vs Cotto - Cotto vs Marg - Mosley vs Marg ....and itll notice that Floyd wasnt involved in any of them. It wont care why he wasnt involved. It wont take into account his issues with Arum. Itll just see a blank slate on Mayweathers resume during his decision to go into retirement and let the above guys beat each other down, remain inactive, or move up weight classes. That, ultimately, will mean his legacy will not be as great as it should have been. It would have been awesome if hed beaten Margarito instead of Baldomir, stuck around for Cotto (before or after his fight Margarito), and beaten Mosley right after hed demolished Margarito. But sadly, he didnt. And that'll be the biggest criticism of his career.
Yet floyd was involved in the biggest fight in boxing history moving up to jmw to fight the champion and ppv star del la hoya. That shits on any of those match up listed. Floyd also went on the beat the **** out of marquez and mosley, marquez who the world just saw beat pac and mosley who the world saw knock the **** out of margarito.
They were certainly BADASS enough to get a shot at him...but Floyd fought easier fights instead. Thats the argument.
Margarito was a nobody as far as a big name in 2007 when Floyd's 1st retirement. He was a tough fighter but beating him would have proved nor did nothing for his career. Rememebr at the time of his retirement, Floyd had just participated in 2 of the biggest non heavyweight PPV fights ever (ODLH & Hatton). Paul Williams, again was a nobody as far as a big name as well. He lost to Quitana (though he did avenge the lost) I do agree with Cotto though, that would have been a big win for resume and PPV numbers. Realize that we are fans. Though I teach boxing, I am not a professional and at this point have not worked with a professional. When you get to the level of Floyd (even when he retired) it becomes more of a focus on the business than just fighting who the general public think you should fight. It's ironic but with the exception of the Judah fight, all of his fights as a welter, have been against champions and/or P4P fighters coming off victories.:think All in all though, it seems as if people bring up these names b/c it makes them feel better about hating on Floyd, b/c their imiganiation of him having problems with these fighters, makes them feel better about not liking him. Real Talk.
When history looks back, they'll simply look at his resume. Much like in 20 years time, the new generation of fans will see the names of Hopkins and RJJ on Calzaghe's. Doesn't tell the whole story, but that's what people will look at. Much like people tend to forget Ali didn't fight in what may be regarded as his prime.