Prime Shane Mosley vs. Miguel Cotto at 147?

An aging Mosley almost beat a prime Cotto so a prime Mosley wins a clear UD IMO.

 

Not much more to say. Spot on.:thumbsup

 

Mosley.

By way of being the busier, more frenetic fighter.

 

Mosley by close, but clear decision. There's a reason his nickname is "Sugar".

 

It would be more competitive, possibly a draw.

Prime Mosley would beat Mayweather though.

 

mosley by 9 rounds. his speed was crazy.

 

Based on what? Mosley's defense is not that good and Floyd would be able to easily outland him. Just look at how many times he was tagged by Cotto.

 

One point of contention though- we haven't any idea whether we have seen a prime Cotto yet. So this thread is best revisited a few years from now.

 

this is a tuff one. you cant call shane an aging mosley when he fought cotto, cuz mosley is still on top of his game. he wooped callazo badly and fought really good against cotto. he was a bit hesitant with cotto but i dont put that down to his age at all.

i'd say Dont know very tough

 

prime mosley would beat cotto, mayweather, williams, margarito and cintron.

 

And Floyd's activity is not what Mosely's is, so how do you so easily claim that Floyd would easily outland him?

 

Prime Mosley beat prime DLH more convincingly than prime Floyd beat an old inactive DLH.

 

Cotto would tag Mayweather just as much as he tagged Mosley.