After being mind****ed, I've come to the conclusion that I'm favouring Freitas. I think Freitas managed to hang in pretty decently with Casamayor although he probably shouldn't have gotten the decision. That being said I thinK Freitas has the style to pressurise Mayweather that bit more and make his power count more, in the way that Chavez did. Freitas would probably stop Roger around about the fourth or fifth in my book. You can't totally dismiss Roger though, considering that sickening power he was carrying at 130.
People often forget how beastly prime Popo truly was. The lingering impressions in most people's minds are from the end of his career, it seems. Then again, most people DKSATBM.
They both had power at 130, Roger probably moreso, but I think Popo had a better chin. I'd go Popo. (Had to take about half an hour to recover from my mind****ing.)