He should have been,but there isn't a whole lot you can do about bad judging.Not a whole lot he could have done against Quarry besides not get knocked down.Flat out beat his behind both times.
Greetings zad! Interesting that you contrasted Terrell w/ Bugner. Bugner was big, strong, and had all the tools to go to the next level but?....IMO had NO heart underneath that left tit! He has no Big career wins and, when presented with an opportunity for greatness, retreated into a shell and made for a very poor effort against Ali in Khala Lampur. Many say Joe was a better ATG than Cooper but Henry copped a UD against a prime Zora Folley in 1958 and that trumps anything that underachiever did. Terrell? By the late 50's he was highly touted but boxing pundits soon realized that he was a big heavy with a fine stiff jab and a right (when he could land it) who enjoyed holding and pawing, given his physical attributes, to win fights. He might have went the distance with Sonny only because of his size and his hugging and holding. I'd like to have seen the two Terrell/Big Cat Williams scraps one of which ended in a draw (Ernie's the type of boring fighter that could make the judges say draw). The best I can say? A big guy with a good jab and good chin (see Bugner)
Hello DK! Actually that wasn't Floyd's last fight, it was his MSG, NY bout with Ali in September 1972, a bout in which Floyd showed himself remarkably well, winning rounds. After Ellis (Sept. 68) Floyd took two years off before beginning his final comeback in Sept. 70 against Lt. Heavy Charlie "Devil" Green. In the early rounds Green butted Floyd and opened a serious gash over his left eye (that *****!) the eye that Ali closed and forced the stoppage in Floyd's last fight (when was Patterson ever stopped due to an 'injury'?) Floyd only wanted an Ali rematch and needed the Bonavena victory to warrant the rematch.
Yeah, I wasn't so sure about it being his last, but my point was that he was at the end of his career... I should have remembered it was the Ali rematch.
This might not sit well with you, Jow, but I had Ellis up in their fight. Patterson was just so tentative for most of the contest. I can see how some might give it to Floyd based on damage done, but on rounds I thought Ellis nipped it.
Who landed more punches, though? Total number of punches connected should be the chief criteria for selecting a winner, followed by consideration of the hardness of blows, ring generalship, who did the most damage in each round, etc. Even if Floyd looked tentative, he may still have connected with more clean blows than Ellis. I haven't watched this fight yet, so I'm not picking a winner. More later.
I scored it 8 rounds for Patterson, 4 even, and 3 for Ellis. Ellis started well, but got his nose broke i think in the 2nd round. Patterson was more assertive, more physical, won most the exchanges, and made it his fight.
I've always shared that view as well, as unpopular as it may be. Typically, Patterson finished strong in the last minute or thirty seconds of every round, but he often allowed Ellis to outwork him in the first two minutes or so of each round. I do believe Patterson should've won at least one of his fights with Quarry, however.
I agree, that is unfair. As "paper" champs go, Ellis was one of the better ones. Unlike a lot of other paper champs, he earned his share of the title by winning a tourney and beating a succession of ranked fighters.
when I look at the career of Quarry he kind of reminds me of the Foreman career but not as accomplished or well managed, Quarry first managed by his father was put in with the best. in the Ellis fight he was not a prime Quarry, he was physically strong and young but still had much to learn by the Mac Foster,Lyle,Shavers fights he knew what he had to do ...he had to utilize his strengths Power and chin and balls....Frazier and Ali were a bit too fast and a notch up and much better managed but Quarry could fight the bangers and his chin neutralized there power, Frazier was a bit more vulnerable but made it up with tremendous heart and firepower, Ali was also a slow,big punching Giant killer with his own kit of tricks......The Ellis fight was not a prime Quarry but speed was not something Jerry thrived on in the opposite corner.
Hi QC; with repeated viewings over the years, I now see the fight as much closer than I originally thought. And I've always mentioned, as I did above, that Floyd gave many rounds away during his career by being so damn passive. After all, here is a guy that took 24 rounds to dispose of Brian London & Roy Harris??? "Ah, to heck with all my talent; I'll just take my time, I don't want to hurt anyone"atsch