How many vehemently disagree? http://www.heavyweightaction.com/heavyweight greats 78-04.html 01. Vitali Klitschko 02. Lennox Lewis 03. Wladimir Klitschko 04. Mike Tyson 05. Larry Holmes 06. Riddick Bowe 07. Evander Holyfield 08. Ike Ibeabuchi 09. Chris Byrd 10. Mike Weaver
1. Holmes 2. Holyfield 3. Tyson 4. Lewis 5. Bowe 6. V. Klitschko 7. W. Klitschko 8. Foreman 9. Witherspoon 10. Byrd Honorable mention to- McCall, Mercer, Tua, and Ibeabuchi
That website should be torn down. I've never been there, but based on that horrendous list, which seems to be plucked from the author's arse, I don't want to go there. Eveb more of a surprise than Vitali on top is Weaver in 10th. Seriously? I like Weaver, I'm a fan, but c'mon...
Worth pointing out twice (double thread in General). This is no small outrage considering he goes on to say he's using the 'Rooney Version' of Tyson in his description.
I haven't thought about final placings, but immediately I'd chuck out the bottom three from that list. Weaver was good, but he didn't distinguish himself from the pack of 80's belt holders. How is he better than say, Witherspoon? Ibeabuchi may or may not have been all that. We'll never know for sure. He has no legacy to speak of. Lists should not be based off speculation, imo. Byrd...no. Fres Oquendo beat him (unoficially) and a one-armed Golota did likewise. Neither guy was all that. He was a gatekeeper but little more. I'd move Evander above Riddick for sure. Bowe won the trilogy, but Holyfield did far, far more in his career. He fought everyone. Bowe barely fought any top names. Holyfield, Holmes and Tyson move above Wladimir, whom I'd drop several spots. All more proven against better opposition. I'd move Lennox above Vitali, no question. I don't see how this is even arguable. I don't know where I'd rank Vitali, but he'd comfortably make the list.
Here's his rendition of 1956-77: 01. Ali 02. Liston 03. Foreman 04. Frazier 05. Norton 06. Terrell 07. Young 08. Quarry 09. Patterson 10. Lyle/Shavers
Lewis Tyson Holmes Holyfield Wlad Bowe Vitali Moorer Byrd Foreman Big drop to the bottom 3 . Mercer, Witherspoon, Thomas, Mccall, Bruno and others all have a decent shout.
I thought the fact that Weaver was behind Byrd and Ibeaubuchi more of a problem than Weaver's presence. Weaver arguably deserves to be in there, Byrd and Ibeaubuchi's achievements are less.
I'd definitely place Lewis and Tyson way above the Klitschko Bros. And to a slightly lesser extent,Holyfiedl and Bowe.