Hall of Famers? Yes or No?

Sven Ottke is a HOF.

 

Dariusz is certainly HOF - material. In his prime, he was a beast, unified the LHW division, clearly beat Griffin and Thadzi who both beat Toney, dominated Hill, knocked out Rocchigiani who had never been knocked down before.

 

Benn should be inspite of his losses. 100% courage. He went over the pond, never lost to an american fighter, and they werent bums either

 

all have a claim but i like to say that the hall of fame is about the boxers not the records. it's about what they did in culture and for there sport. so to all those poeple saying barry mac shouldnt be in the hall got to remember he united a country together which is more than say most of the other hof.

 

I see 3 yeses

 

The only thing Ottke should be put in is a ****ing prison for serial theft

 

If you put it like that then , yes barry mac does deserve to be there, totally

 

with the HOF criteria as it is.

Riddick Bowe - yes (barely. being the legit HW champ is a strong point for me, hell even inge johansson is in)
Hector Camacho - yes
Donald Curry - no
Esteban De Jesus - yes
Buddy McGirt - yes (barely)
Nigel Benn - yes
Chris Eubank - yes
Julian Jackson - no
Steve Collins - no
Carlos De Leon - yes
Diego Corrales - yes
Jose Luis Ramirez - no
Julio Cesar Vasquez - no
Genaro Hernandez - yes (barely as well)
Ernesto Marcel - yes
Dariusz Michalczewski - yes
Sven Ottke - a big NO!

 

Riddick Bowe - yes
Hector Camacho - yes
Donald Curry - no
Esteban De Jesus - yes
Buddy McGirt - yes
Nigel Benn - yes
Chris Eubank - yes
Julian Jackson - no
Steve Collins - no
Carlos De Leon - yes
Diego Corrales - yes
Jose Luis Ramirez - no
Julio Cesar Vasquez - no
Genaro Hernandez - no
Ernesto Marcel - yes
Dariusz Michalczewski - no
Sven Ottke - no

 

Buddy a HOF (as a fighter)... but Collins and Dariusz no... someone has to explain that to me...