Of course he would... Tito had crazy stamina..Tito had crazy power, and great timing and accuracy....It would be lights out for Tony... maybe similar to the Campas fight, but I soubt Tony drops Tito.
Sure tito would give tony a gruesome ass whipping but the fight would be pure fireworks while it lasted. Margo would come in shape with determination in his eyes and give us a Atg classic for the ages.
Trinidad would make Mosley's KO of Plastaco look gentle and loving. Margarito gets shipped back to TiaJuana in box with Tito's autograph.
A sustained, one-sided, brutal beating. It would actually be better for Tony if he had an average chin - at least then he'd get stopped early. There's nothing he could do against Tito except eat huge power-shots until he crumbles or the ref/his corner show some mercy. It would be so bad that some fans might start feeling sorry for Marg.