What are your thoughts on James Slater's Placement of Tim Bradley as P4P #2?

Feels designed to **** people off and bring attention to his ridiculous views on the fight. Self-promotion.

 

That's crazy. He doesn't belong with Mayweather, Pac, Marquez, Martinez, Ward, and Donaire and the Klits should arguably be higher than him. He should be 9th, ahead of Froch, Cotto, Dawson

 

Slaters a dumbass for that. IMO Pac wasn't impressive vs a guy he should have steamrolled but he still easily won so Bradley should 100% not be ahead of him but I think Pacs poor performance vs Bradley followed by the deserved loss to Marquez justifies ranking Marquez and possibly Sergio and/or Ward ahead of him. At the same time Timmy held in there and won rounds vs Pac so he moves into the top 10 imo anywhere from 7-10 is acceptable.

1. Floyd Mayweather JR
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Sergio Martinez
4. Manny Pacquaio
5. Andre Ward
6. Wlad Klitschko
7. Nonito Donaire
8. Timothy Bradley
9. Yuriorkis Gamboa
10. Chad Dawson

1 and 2 are not debatable. 3-5 are interchangeable and hard to rank imo. 6-7 are interchangeable and 8-10 are interchangeable....I can even see and argument for Cotto or Froch in place of any of the guys I have from 8-10.

 

A complete embarrassment.

I hope it's some sort of joke.

 

I stopped reading when I did not see Andre Ward's name anywhere near the top, lol

 

1. Ward
2. TIM
3. NONITO
4. PAC
5. COTTO

 

Is he a knee grow? That6 would explain ni9t.

 

You got #1 right, but you missed badly on #5. Seriously, I do not really get why people still have Cotto ahead of Canelo on their P4P lists.