Lets say that Oscar won all his major fights.

He ****ing beat Trinidad :-(
If he went through all his fights undefeated? Top 5-8 ATG.

 

Win or lose, I Cant think of any fighter that comes close to fighting so many PFP #1 fighters.

The man truly ducked no one.

 

His resume win or lose is possibly a top 2 or 3 ATG resume as far as multiple weights go. It's crazy. and he was high and wearing girls clothes a lot of the time

 

They wouldn't be P4P #1 because Oscar would be there.

But tbh there will always be ways to discredit a mans resume. I can already forsee a couple for a few of those names

 

It's what ESB excels at.

 

Yeah, if Oscar had beaten Floyd and Pac it would have been "oscar was too big" especially if he had kept his 0 like the thread says.

 

Number 1 at it wouldn't be close.

 

I would have rated him as the greatest of all time, easily. Top 20 if he beat half the guys that beat him.

Hell, he beat tito, a roided Sugar (unofficially), and almost took out a prime Mayweather at 35 years old. He was so close to even more greatness. Still easily an atg though, when it was all said and done.

He was the reason I even got into the sport.

 

Winky disagrees.

 

Then Winky is a lying sack-o-shite, he ducked Oscar. 6 million was not enough for him.

Nice try son.:deal

 

# 2 all time behind SRR.

 

Surely he'd crash most top 10's quite easily?
But if the sun was shining in Stalingrad Europe might be Deutchsland.
Old Oscar gets a hard time but I think his resume of opponents stands up to anyone's in the modern game,and with the exception of the ridiculous weight he agreed to fight Pacquaio,he never took a real beating south of 154.
And he made the sport bankable again IMO.

 

Then he would probably go down as one of the few.