The result would be obvious with a 2 armed Vitali that has never been outboxed, but by a one armed Vitali I have him by UD. It would be a closer fight with Haye taking 3-4 rounds, but 1 armed Vitali dominates the other rounds and wins a clear decision victory just like he did on Chisora.
that was a terrible shoulder injury, which prevents movement without severe pain. The toughest guy in boxing (Vitali) had to quit with that, I wonder what someone who bitched about a toe injury would do.