Because,,,,,,,,,,,,,Cassius Clay was 'not' blinded. It was all part of the 'ruse'. And those weren't hard body punches that Sonny was throwing at Clay in Round 5. It is very easy to 'pull' punches like that.
Well the rematch is what it is. But c'mon guys, the first fight? Are you serious? I had the impression that Liston had no ****ing clue what do against such a slick mover. Liston had wins over Williams, Valdes, Foley, Patterson (won the gold medal as middleweight), Machen.... But Clay was a complete different breed. He was at his absolute best at that time.
It was a very unsatisfactory and farcical event that the mainstream revisionist history has done well to clean up. Not necessarily an outright fix, but a pathetic affair for sure.
This is the "proof" cited by a majority of people that the fight wasn't fixed. It has become an axiom that Liston blinded Clay in order to win. This would have been extremely easy to script and fake. Clay running around acting like he couldn't see with Liston trying to finish him off- Instant proof the fight wasn't fixed. I can't think of anything else that could have been staged that would have been as effective.
Almost everyone at the time interpreted the blinding incident as an accident - either Liston's liniment for his cut got directly into Clay's eyes via CLAY'S gloves, or something accidental in the Clay corner. Only Clay himself said "his corner are dirty", Angelo Dundee said he didn't think so.
Clay greatly embellished the story as time went on. He later claimed that before the Terrell fight he was approached by a mysterious figure offering to sell him a small bottle of stuff to use on his gloves to blind Terrell. Clay said he recognized him as being in Liston's corner during the first fight.
I'm trying to figure out that 'delayed action liniment'. Lets see, Sonny chases Cassius for 3-minutes of Round 4, landing an assortment of medium left jabs to the face. Cassius moves very well, and fires off snappy left jabs, which land. During the round, there was 'no blinking' or 'squinting' from Clay, and not one complaint to the Referre Barney Felix. Not once did Sonny, jamb the heel of his glove into Clay' eyes, and there was no contact from a clinch. Then, miracously at the end of the Round, with the 'hand-held creepy camera' utilized by the cameraman aiming directly into Clay's corner, and with a full view of Cassius and not blocked off by his cornerman, the cameraman and the watching viewers have a perfect view of Cassius Clay blinking. Can somebody on this planet please tell me exactly what liniment has a 'delayed action'.
Senor, You'll have to ask that shadowy figure in the trench coat and fedora who was in Liston's corner.
There is no proof either way. But to me nothing suggests that the fight was fixed. If you wanted to you could say many fights were fixed if there especially if there are unusual circumstances, the main argument being that 'you can't prove it was fixed but you can't prove it wasn't fixed either.' That's the way most conspiracy theories go, a lot boils down to personal opinion/interpration. I think the results of the poll in the case are pretty conclusive.
The results of the poll are conclusive of the opinions of the posters who have answered it. Which is fine- that is what I asked for when I posted it. I think most of what you wrote is reasonable and I can't disagree with it. My only point is that the blinding incident proves nothing, because it would have been very easy to fake. Also, as Senor Pepe has pointed out, there are problems with that story when you look at the footage of the fight.
You people are ridicules, you seem to have some weird jealous personal vendetta against Ali, and act like you know for certain his fights were a fix despite having no proof. You have the nerve to attempt to tarnish his rep by saying not only were the wins fixed, but that he was in on it. Fact is Muhammad just made Liston look silly, deal with it and move to a new topic.
noone can provide any proof that either fight was fixed and there's no good reason for anyone to believe. it's likt the mystique of liston is so great you can't imagine him being doubly outclassed.
Bill B, Thanks for the acknowledgement. Listen, to Announcer Steve Ellis at the end of the 4th Round. Cassius walked back to his corner, with no apparent eye problems. Steve Ellis, 'At this point we're going in, to look at Cassius Clay's corner.' "We'll get that shot, right into the corner.' It was like it was scripted. Steve Ellis was a 'quiet player' in that farce in Miami.
The first fight was not a fix. Liston underestimated his opponent, didn't train properly, and paid the price. The second fight was probably fixed, though Clay almost certainly didn't know.