What's more impressive? Dominating one division for a decade or multi division champ

I think it'd depend on how strong the division was that said fighter dominated.

 

Ultimately, it'll come down to level of opposition. Dominating a division for a decade will not mean a great deal if it's a fairly weak era overall. Same as if you were a multi division champ, but decided to hop jump and skip your way past the tougher title holders around and took on the weaker ones.

But all things being equal, I would side with dominating for a decade over moving up a couple of weightclasses.

 

Depends, because it's not the same as when Armstrong held the featherweight, lightweight and welterweight titles all at the same time. Today somebody could hold 122, 126 and 130lbs titles.....it's three titles in three weight classes however that still doesn't come close to what Armstrong had to do.

 

Since you clarified we're talkin about strong eras and legit world champs, I'd say the multi division champ. If you can beat the true world champ in a couple different divisions, it's better than just beatin 1 world champ and several strong contenders.

 

I think a fighter should have at least 5 or 6 fights as champion before moving on to conquer a new division. Just beating the champion is not enough for me, its about styles and durability. On most cases I'd say its harder to stay at the top than it is to get there.

 

Neither for me. It depends how good how great your opposition is. Too many people get caught up on longetivity in one division or division hopping thats good I guess, but not if your doing it against B levels or former greats.

 

Sadly nowadays jumping divisions is often just an excuse for avoiding the better fighters in your own division.

In this case, being the champ in one division and defending against all on comers is the more impressive path to take IMO.

 

Multi if they keep challenging themselves and fight the division best.

 

Yeah, but that could just be a matter of styles. Defend 5 or 6 times and you've left no stone unturned. The problem is fighters today refuse to fight often enough and are spoiled once they hit elite status.

 

Agreed on all counts.