If Floyd retires this year after beating Guerrero and Canelo

That's like after Ortiz Martinez and may agree @ 156 catch then the ***** Martinez comes in at 160 against a WW like really? That's some bs gets no credit.

 

just like the lineal champion baldonir who beat Judah..

 

2 Pounds don't make that big of a difference. Sorry.

Catchweight was @ 144. Floyd weighed 146. 2 Pounds do not, in any way, change the outcome of that fight.

Butthurt pacturds are really reaching nowadays

Guess what? Floyd's a megastar, ATG. Pacturds... are sleeping. And will be lucky to finish top 150 ATG. LUCKY

 

Your a ****ing dumb ass, that title was vacant

 

Then why the **** are all you *****s on about the two pounds Cotto took off to face Manny if they do not make a difference?:deal

 

:rofl:roflatsch you've gone psycho over the past few weeks

you've always been psycho :rofl

 

ok.. I think both didn't really wanted the fight as they were making so god damn matching fighting easier opponents.. And both have been very dissapointing to me in their matchmaking Pac since the DLH fight and Floyd since Castillo II really I rank pac around 50 and floyd around 40 now.. While i do think Pac has the best win of the 2 ( Barrera 1 )

I think Floyd is way more gifted and could ve been a lot higher if he took on more challengers. Especially Zoo, Cotto in 08 and Martinez now.

 

That's it around guys like Arguello and Sanchez but bellow guys like SRL and Duran

 

The weight wasn't much of an issue. The time he fought Cotto was very... "convenient". He was plastered by margacheato and then given a gift decision vs clottey. cotto was ready to lose to anyone at that point.

 

The rules for judging manny and Floyd are very different, in case you didn't know jackass.

manny can do what he wants, fight who he wants, and reap the benefits, whether he wins, loses, or gets KTFO6.

Floyd is either always dodging, cherry picking, or beating women. The only time he can legitimately earn credit is when he fights lineal champions at least two weight classes above. Anything else is ***** status

Get with the program, Larry

 

Because contemporary fans are in denial over personal feelings.

Wait 20 years. Then we'll see who is correct.

Top 15 easily if he retires undefeated, with additional wins to his current resume over Guerrero and Alvarez. And who knows? Perhaps Alvarez goes on to become a dominant HOF'er himself, further enhancing that win.

 

atsch Guerrero and Alvarez are nobodies. In 20 years nobody will know / care who they are.

Floyd has a pretty good resume on paper, but when you look at the context and who he actually beat and when it doesn't add up.

Corrales, Castillo, Hernandez, Oscar and Hatton were all solid to good wins, bottom line.

The rest are a bunch of nobodies, paper champs, or shot / over the hill fighters.

Floyd is an ATG due to his multiple titles / weight divisions, and (for now) undefeated record but it lacks substance. He's ducked a lot of tough fights, and history will remember that.