Can the HW version of RJJ go through k2's combined Resume with 5 or less losses???

Interesting deabte.

Styles make fights. To beat Roy at heavy, you'd have to walk him down. Obviously if anyone catches him clean he's a gonner, but would they have had the opportunity? Look at Wlad vs Haye. Haye frustrated him with his movement and he couldn't land on him flush.

I think Sanders would have been a very hard fight for Roy.

I honestly believe that Roy had a good chance of beating the old faded version of Lewis that stuggled with Vitali. I don't think he could have beaten a prime Lennox, but he definitely had a chance with the 2003 version.

I think Roy could also outbox Haye to a points win. Haye has copied his style by watching Roy, but he hasn't got the incredible reflexes and footwork that Roy had. Roy beats him in every department apart from obvious power.

Roy was so fast, and I think it would off set a lot of heavyweights. Speed causes a variety of problems. Haye's got a shaky chin himself, and Roy bulked up to 200 can punch. Also, Haye has got a terrible defence.

What would Haye's game plan have been?

I don't think he'd go to him to try and knock him out, because I think he'd be concerned about taking a shot. Roy was a lot quicker than Haye. Like I say if Haye catches him, then Roy's asleep. But if Roy gets his attention early, then I think he could have frustrated him to a points win.

Someone like Vitali would have walked to Roy and he would have been prepared to have taken his shots, because he could take a shot. Haye in my opinion, wouldn't have been able to adopt those tactics.

I think this thread will turn into a farce, because people will just imagine the Tarver, Johnson and Lebedev knockouts, and say that Roy loses vs a jab or 1 round KO etc.

 

Sanders L x2
Lewis L
Brewster L
Haye L
Peter L x2
Thompson L x2
Arreola L
Chagaev L
Byrd L
Chambers L
Ibrag L
Brock L

 

Roy's greatest assets, his speed and reflexes, are likely diminished at heavyweight. Add that with the fact that he wasn't a huge hitter, and that spells trouble.

K2s combined resume is pretty much ****, but asking a middleweight to go through it is a bit much. Without the pop to keep guys off him, he gets walked down and taken out a lot.

 

Lets see, a career middleweight with shaky whiskers fighting over 100 Hws. HMM wonder howd that turn out

atsch

 

Sam Peter would have sent Roy to the Morgue.

Seems like a troll thread

 

I dont know if Roy would have lost all of these fights but he would have had a chance to lose most or all of them. Too dificult to make up the weight, hight and power difference considering Roy's ability to take a punch.

 

Honestly, Herbie Hide would have KTFOed Jones. Anyone see that version that Vitali beat? He was like Mike Tyson light, only with a shaky ass chin. Which Roy would not have been able to crack.

 

Byrd beats him
Corrie Sanders steamrolls him
Sam Peter Will catch him sooner or later.
McCline that fought Wlad and Byrd stops him late.
Ibragimov stops him late in a close fight.
Chagaev, Haye, Chambers all beat him.
Solis and Chisora stop him.

and he would loose a couple more by lucky punches from maybe Arreola or Hide

I can see him schooling Adamek though.

 

Well Ruiz would be of been one of the best names on Vitalis resume if he had beat him and he would be a Top 5 win for Wlad.

 

Think he would have to retire after the Lewis fight if he made it that far.

 

Is this some sort of sick joke?