Is Guerrero a better opponent than a prime Pacquiao?

No

 

****ing **** thread

 

So what are these live bodies Guerrero fought? I can't see anyone on his record that beats that version of Marg or Clottey, maybe one guy that beats Mosley. For that matter, Guerrero gets routed by Marg, and probably gets beat down by Clottey too

 

Lol. Some *****s are actually being serious? Like when Cotto was shot when Pac fought him but unshot whem Floyd fought him?

 

This fight is predictable. Mayweather will win a 12 round UD.

 

He dominated a crafty Casamayor, top lw Katsidis and took on an undefeated Aydin in his first ww fight, Berto was also fresh with only 1 loss. Guerrero was Marquez mandatory for some time and never landed the big fights. Khan also passed when they offered him the fight. Im not saying Guerrero has better names but they were fresh live opponents and Pacs have been in the tail end of their careers so thats why i said i dont know how well Pac would have done cuz the times he fought a live opponent vs Marquez and Bradley, he all of a sudden, coincidentally looked 'old.' At least stylistically Guerrero has the length, size and versatility,ability to adjust vs a guy like Mayweather.

 

Guerrero is most definitely better than the 2008/2009 Manny Pacquiao. More footspeed, better handspeed, more explosive combination punching, better timing, superior angle attacker, and far more power in that dynamite straight left of his than Pacquiao's.

 

They weren't fresh opponents. Casa was washed up worse than Mosley, and would get his head taken off by Shane. Katsidis retired shortly thereafter, after never having won a title. Aydin is a tiny welter and a borderline bum that Soto Karass handled better. So all you're left is unranked Berto, coming off a PED suspension. You ever notice Berto is the only name fighter Ortiz managed to beat in 5 tries?

 

Guerrero is shite and you know it,don't be so ****ing shallow and give Manny his props you ****ing fan boy.

 

No.

 

Lmao.....lmao....no

 

Hatton, Clottey, Margarito and Mosley havnt won a fight since they fought Pac. They were hand chosen while Guerrero was building towards a big fight which nobody would give him. Again the point is if Pac was his best when fighting a beatdown Cotto with no trainet and spent the next few years handpicking opponents, ill never know if he'd do better vs Mayweather than Guerrero. But stylistically, id give Guerrero the edge.

 

:rofl

 

Are you purposely trying to sound stupid in this thread? Cause it's working.

 

Haha. Someone doesn't understand sarcasm.


Honestly, put Guerrero into Pacquiao's shoes during Pac's welterweight run. Put him in with Margarito, Cotto, Hatton, Clottey, Bradley, Marquez, and Mosley.

Tell me if he comes out of it winning 7 out of 8 fights.