I think you're on crack, Bradley at 3, no Donaire, Pacquiao or Rigondeaux and Dawson, Garcia and Hopkins should not be on the list
It's better than The Ring's but I agree with everyone who's said Bradley is too high, I think he lost the Pac fight, and Juan Man KO of Manny didn't do him any favors in the list and nor did him going life and death with Providikov. Dawson doesn't quite make mine but I agree he should be a candidate- he beat Hopkins comfortable and noones done that since Roy Jones in 1932 Mine would be: 1- Floyd Mayweather Jr 2- Andre Ward 3- Juan Manuel Marquez 4- Wladimir Klitschko 5- Manny Pacquiao 6- Abner Mares 7- Guillermo Rigondeaux 8- Nontio Donaire 9- Sergio Martinez 10- Carl Froch
here is mine 1. Floyd Mayweather 2. Juan Manuel Marquez 3. Andre Ward 4. Sergio Martinez 5. Guillermo Rigondeaux 6. Timothy Bradley 7. Manny Pacquiao 8. Carl Froch 9. Abner Mares 10. Canelo Alvarez
I like Hopkins but come on, he is no longer a top p4p fighter. He can't beat the best guys at LHW or SMW. Bradley is def too high. Danny Garcia doesn't belong yet. And Canelo has made the cut in my opinion.
Other than Dawson which of the Light Heavy's do you favour to beat 'Nard? At SMW I'd say Ward definitely wins, and possibly Kessler and Froch too but I don't say that with a great deal of conviction.
I have no problem with your list except one thing......Bradley is too phvcking high for my liking. I cannot even begin to see how it is explain why he is that high.