Who's Had The Better Career, Judah-Paulie?

Paulie had a good win in his last fight against Broner when Broner was the 1/25 favorite but in hindsight when Broner proves to be another Audley Harrison it won't be that impressive so I'm saying Judah.

 

who has a better career?? I think it is judah but more successful i pick Paulie. Afterall, he is an commentator and still makes money for fights.

Zab is more known for his ABC belts and unification, and also his will to quit fights, lol....
Paulie is known for his weak punches, still, i like paulie's style better... my opinion

 

Paulie got spanked and dropped by all 3 worldlevel guys he shared the ring with. Judah actually could really compete with a couple of them.
Plus more trinkets, means Judah is the clear victor in this/

 

Judah in his prime was an elite fighter, Paulie never has been

that been said, Paulie is doing better nowadays

 

If anything Judah massively underachieved and Paulie Overachieved - even then Judah's career > Paulie's.

Judah was once Undisputed champ at WW.

Lets not forget recent accomplishments aswell, apart from khan fight (bad style match up, couldnt deal with someone actually faster than him) + Khan was at Peak), Judah has Beaten Mathysse (i Had it 114-113 LM) but it was close enough for judah to win, Fought well against Garcia, won a belt (against mabuza (i think?)) that he lost to khan.

 

Judah by a pretty wide, or at least obvious, margin.

 

i am not going to cover this and say he couldn't compete at world class, because he did great but reason i dont like judah is he quit alot... he was doing well against mayweather and quit/broke, same with Cotto even with the low blows, and even against Khan..

 

Judah has the hardware to beat anyone, but he doesn't have the mental game to hold himself together or the brains to implement his talent.

Paulie lacks hardware, but he is mentally far superior and can maximize his chance in the ring.

Judah failed to reach his potential and paulie somehow exceeded his potential. I pick Paulie to win this fight at this stage of their careers

 

Judah has had the better career and its not even close.

Judah was the Lineal Champ at 147. We can end it right there.

 

Judah is obviously a good deal more accomplished and has a better resumé. Paulie has generally shown more character in his career though..

 

Zab