Should James "Lights Out" Toney go into the IBHOF?

he gets in of course, but not a top notcher due to the drugs thing.

 

Offff course. Hate his trash talk and disrespectful physique all you want,
but the man was an absolute picasso in the ring and he accomplished
enough to warrant entry. Also, just imagine what JT would have accomplished
with a Bernard Hopkins type work ethic and clean living standard. :yikes

 

No, there shouldn't be any room for PED users.

 

2 time PED cheater, so no way

 

Let him in but just keep him away from the buffet table.

 

Seems he gets a free pass on the steroids more so than other boxers...

 

Perhaps he should, but not because of his boxing the last few years. Toney of a billion years ago? Perhaps..............

 

Toney belongs in the top 50-80 ATG.

From middleweight to heavyweight . Starting at 157 and fighting big punchers like who weigh 240-250pounds Name me another fighter who has done it.

 

Don't confuse the Toney of today who looks he lives at IHOP compared to the brilliant young boxer Toney who without question belongs in the IBHOF.

 

True. People make a big deal of small men moving up in weight. That's almost a 100 pound difference fighting real men.

 

Juice use

 

This

 

With or without juice?