I think pretty much everyone established Martinez as the winner of the Cintron fight and Matthyse for the Alexander fight. The Williams and Judah fights were close fights that could have gone either way. I personally had Martinez beating Williams in the first fight but had Judah winning a close decision in the Matthyse fight. Either way, they both were highly ranked AFTER those fights. Martinez fought and beat Pavlik after the first Williams fight and became the lineal champ. Matthyse could of become the IBF champ if he didn't fight Peterson at 141, but he instead chose to fight Garcia and lost. I'm not sure why you're trying to call the Garcia fight a robbery. Matthyse clearly lost that fight.
All close fights go to the hometown fighter. Foreigners basically start with a 2 point handicap. You basically have to think of getting at least 8 rounds as a foreigner and 5 of those have to be convincing.