Better career James Toney or Floyd Mayweather?

James Toney

1) TKO prime Michael Nunn. Nunn beat Iran Barkley and Sumbu Kalambay

2) 1-0-1 vs Mike McCallum - better opponent than anyone on Mayweather's resume

3) lost to prime Roy Jones - better than anyone Floyd faced

4) lost 2 fights that could go either way to Montell Griffin - better than anyone Floyd faced outside of Marquez. Gave prime Roy Jones a tough fight in the first fight before Jones ruined his career.

Meanwhile, Floyd lost to Castillo in the first fight and barely got past Maidana - who his uncle said beat no one impressive

5) Moved up to heavyweight, being a former middleweight. Beat a past prime Holyfield - better than a welterweight Floyd moving up one measly class to beat a past prime Oscar DLH who was 1-3 of his last 4 factoring in the Sturm robbery

6) Also beat John Ruiz, drew with Hasim Rahman, 2 disputed decisions with the bum C-class Sam Peter (who was able to trouble the bum Klitscko with 3 knockdowns) - this is a middleweight fighting weak heavyweights as opposed to a welterweight fighting weak jr middleweights




Floyd BUMweather

1) Corrales - somehow was ranked ahead of Hopkins and Lennox Lewis, and right behind Roy Jones. people think he was amazing, but not true. Crushed by journeyman Clottey, life and death with Castillo, and a disputed decision to avenge a loss to Casamayor. never beat one elite fighter EVER

2) Castillo - never beat ONE elite fighter EVER and still beat the bum Mayweather. Clearly Castillo is no Roy Jones Jr

3) Ortiz, Guerrero, Baldomir, Judah - all bums and paper champions. If there was one title per class none of these bums would come close to holding it. Judah was the so-called "undisputed champion" but who did he beat for that title?

4) Genaro Hernandez - average fighter, only win is against a past prime Azumah

5) Gatti - Mayweather repeatedly stated that Gatti was a C-class fighter

6) Oscar - when Toney was moving up to heavyweight to beat past prime Holyfield, Floyd decided to fight Oscar (who lost or was gifted 99% of the big fights in his career) who had not legitimately won a fight in 3 of his last 4

7) Marquez - floyd made this guy come up 2 classes to fight him instead of being a man like Toney who moved up to fight much bigger men. Instead of making Marquez move up to fight him, Roy Jones was the guy who moved up to fight Toney

8. Hatton - never beat one elite fighter. Tzyus name is off of Zab Judah who lost every big fight he was in. Undefeated Montell Griffin or Ricky Hatton? Not a tough choice. Hatton is nobody

9) Maidana - Roger Maywather - never beat one impressive fighter

10) 40 yr old Shane Mosley is not as impressive as a washed up Holyfield when you're a natural middleweight

11) Cotto - washed up, past prime, beaten down by plaster Margarito. good win, but not better than McCallum or Nunn



Toney has by far the better resume

 

what does money have to do with anything? i guess you think Tyson is better than Ali then

Toney went from 160 to heavyweight

If Mayweather moved up to from 130 to 175 i guarantee he'd slur his speech if he ran into Hopkins, prime Sergio, Kovalev, Adonis, Dawson.

can't blame you though. you would want to fight bums your whole career for a lot of money. but that doesnt make a better resume