Before You Replay: Your Scorecards Here

Easy night's work for JC:

This content is protected

 

Newbie :rofl

116-112 Calzagne

 

And like others, I could easily jumped on the bandwagon and say Hopkins won the fight, but he never. I'm not biased. Amsterdam, you are. Not because you had Calzaghe winning, but how you had him winning.

 

116-111 Calzaghe (rounds 1, 2 and 10 for Hopkins)

Victory by way of "workrate"

That said Hopkins looked impressive considering his age - but as versus Taylor, he simply works too little...

 

Not a joke, you picked Bernard to begin with, 9-3 is also a fair score, you can't possibly give Hopkins more than 3 rounds here.

 

i had it 117-112 Calzaghe

 

115-112 Calzaghe

There seems to be this phenomenon where a knockdown can really effect people's scoring of an entire fight. Calzaghe got knocked down in the first round and apparently there was a carryover effect into the other rounds, which I find to be amazing. Instead of isolating that one round, people let the knockdown blend into the rest of their scoring when Calzaghe clearly made up for the early deficit.

 

I'm making a pap of myself? All of the proven good scorer's here scored it wide for Calzaghe, that was in no way close.

 

Calzaghe winning 115 - 113

RD1: 10 – 8 Hopkins
RD2: 9 – 10 Calzaghe
RD3: 10 – 9 Hopkins
RD4: 10 – 9 Hopkins
RD5: 9 – 10 Calzaghe
RD6: 9 – 10 Calzaghe
RD7: 9 – 10 Calzaghe
RD8: 9 – 10 Calzaghe
RD9: 9 – 10 Calzaghe
RD10: 10-9 Hopkins
RD11: 9 – 10 Calzaghe
RD12: 10 – 10 Draw

 

116 - 112 for Joe

 

Same.

 

I picked Hopkins, but he lost by 3-4 points. He won more than 2 rounds. Bottom line is, both were poor. And for you having Calzaghe winning so wide, that makes his performance look even worse. You can't always win good, sometimes ugly.


Calzaghe won, no question.