Your top 10 ratings at Welterweight

1.Mayweather
2.Pacquiao
3.Bradley
4.Marquez
5.Maidana
6.Brook
7.Thurman
8.Porter
9.Guererro
10.Khan

 

Lmfao
Bradley could only have chance at beating jmm again on that whole list.
Talk about over rating a ww reign before the reign even begins

 

Its amazing how this forum loves to Hype fighters. Brook goes from a man known for beating euro level fighters, gets called a ducker, hypejob etc to beating a man famous for stopping an old semi retired Malignaggi. He recently went life and death wth a man who has 7 losses and yet now he is top 5 welter.

Maidana is a 2 weight world champ and was the man every ****er feared at 140 a few years back. He has some solid wins, Broner was rated top ten pfp when he beat him. Khan has solid wins and is a former 2 time unified champion, he beat Maidana when most said he wouldnt dare fight him. Yet you all rate Brook way ahead of them due to winning a split decision against an unproven fighter.

So many fighters come and go and you all lap it up. Anyone remember Trout, Donaire, Juanma Lopez, Mike Jones, Bute of late?! The same Hype and attention was placed on these guys only for them to fade away. Brook has left it far too late IMO, i like him but lets see him in a fight with a guy his own size. A real WW, Bradley would eat him up even with his lack of Power. Even someone like Ortiz or Broner to see where he is at.

 

1 JMM
2 Thurman
3 Floyd
4 Pac
5 Bradley
6 Brook
7 Chino
8 Khan
9 Rios
10 Devon

 

1. Mayweather
2. Pacman
3. Maidana
4. Brooks
5. Bradley
6. Marquez
7. Porter
8. Thurman
9. Alexander
10. Khan

 

pound for pound Bradley and JMM rank higher than Maidana and Brooks though... juts my opinion

 

I agree too. Khan needs to be behind all of them.

 

1. Mayweather
2. Pacquiao
3. Bradley
4. Marquez
5. Brook
6. Porter
7. Alexander
8. Maidana
9. Thurman
10. Khan

It's all a matter of "who beat who". Thurman isn't higher because he hasn't fought any of these guys, unfortunately.

 

Porter beat Malignaggi in a more convincing fashion than Cotto and Hatton, doesnt mean he is anywhere near those 2.

I rate Maidana on his wins over Ortiz, at the time that was a huge win and most were shocked at the outcome. His fights with Khan and Kotelnik and then his KO over Broner, as much as i hate Broner he is a good fighter.

And most importantly his performance over the best fighter on the planet. Fighting a close decision with an ATG is surely better than Brook fighting a SD with Porter.

It wasnt just ******s that had Broner pound for pound, most in the boxing world did. I never i cant stand the guy but i recognise his talents.

 

1) Amir 'King' Khan.
2) Kell 'Special K' Brook.
3) Frankie 'Funtime' Gavin.
4) Lee 'Powerhouse' Purdy.
5) Junior '2Sweet' Witter.
6) Denton 'The Lion' Vassell.
7) Bradley 'Zzzzzz' Skeete.
8) Colin 'Heartless' Lynes.
9) Chad Gaynor.
10) Glenn 'Big' Foot.