Max Kellerman has Manny ahead of Floyd on his all time P4P list

Any fool knows Manny is the greatest fighter of his generation

 

so does that mean the smart ones know Manny isn't?

 

LOL. Manny is waaaaaaaaaaaay ahead of Floyd. win or lose this fight.

 

with a great resume, yes but we all know floyd's resume is not that great...its mediocre to say the least

 

Prime for prime Manny was more impressive as a boxer. So I can see why he'd be higher on the list than Floyd. Mayweather was also excellent in his prime but Pacquiao had that wow factor. He transcended the sport and caught the attention of people who aren't even interested in boxing because of his devastating victories.

 

got to love all these fools that proclaiming that either Mayweather or Pacman (depending on which one of the two make em hard!)is miles better than the other, give the reasons as to why, usually slaughtering the other fighter and taking away from them ie mayweather stayed in his comfort zone etc. then say that if they then beat this "overated opponent" it then catapults them into top 5 P4P of all time how can one win do this in your opinion if your taking away the accomplishments of the other fighter. the only way u can justify such a leap in the all time rankings is if you actually believe that the other fighter is right up there as well.

I cant fathom why people just cant look forward to the fight, we have waited so long for. fukn embrace it, enjoy it we finally got he fight we wanted between the greatest two fighters of our era. Both are the best of our time stop with stupid comments diminishing the opponents achievements cos all it will do in the end is
A: make u look stupid if the other guy wins
B: take away the achievment of the fighter that wins.

Im goin for a DRAW !!!!

 

:deal

 

I doubt you will give Floyd credit when he kicks Pacquiao's ass. It's not in you because your hatred poisons your reason and judgment

 

People don't realise it's actually possible to appreciate both fighters. I am picking Floyd because he is the better boxer but that is not to say I disrespect Pacquiao. I just know Pacquiao has flaws that play to Mayweather's strengths.

 

:rofl

You already said it's not a level field, remember? So why do you keep saying this?

Floydaholic, my ass. You're a hater. I'm more neutral than you are.

 

Pac has some catchweight fights for titles. (Cotto and Margarito)
Also, Pac has a glaring lack of title defenses in several of the weight classes he competed in. No title defenses at 135, 140, or 154. Winning a title, then dropping it right away and leaving the division doesn't exactly do a lot for his 135 pound, 140 pound, or 154 pound resumes for example. (That isn't 'fighting everyone')

You could make a legitimate argument that Pacquiao has done jack in 3 of the divisions he took a title in: 135 (1 fight), 140 (1 fight), and 154 (1 fight - catchweight). And his 147 pound resume is 60% against non-ranked opposition.

Fact is Pacquiao's resume above 130 pounds isn't very great. He's been protected for the most part. Cotto was his last real tough test, and even that was at a catchweight. I expect this reality to be thoroughly exposed May 2nd. People are in for a shock.

And I'm not even saying it's wrong they are protecting him. Pac has moved up a lot of weight classes. It should be expected. But let's call it for what it is. May 2nd people will see why it really took this long to make this fight. It would have ruined Pac's superstar earning power.