Watched and scored some of Floyd Mayweather's historically controversial fights

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by frankenfrank, Apr 28, 2015.



  1. frankenfrank

    frankenfrank Boxing Junkie Full Member

    13,963
    54
    Aug 18, 2009
    Rounds that could b scored evenly marked by asterisks.


    MRM vs FM #1:
    Maidana : 1 , 2 , 3 , *4* , *5* , *6* , 11 .
    Mayweather : *7* , *9* ,
    Even: 8 , 10 , 12


    Maidana (actually) won: 118:113 or 120:116 depending on how convinced 1 likes 2b while scoring each rd.


    referee : Tony Weeks . Biased referee , pro Mayweather , prevented Maidana's inside success .

    Michael Cernex : 114-114 (draw) , Burt Clements : 117-111 , Dave Moretti : 116-112 both for Mayweather.




    MRM vs FJM #2:
    Maidana: 4 , *12*
    Mayweather : *10* , *11*

    Either 120:119 4 Maidana or a 118:118 draw.


    Referee : Kenny Bayless
    Judges :

    Maidana might have bitten Floyd only after Floyd intentionally palmed his mouth & nose with his glove intentionally.
    Floyd was also warned by Bayless for using the elbow.




    JLC vs FJM #1:
    JLC : *3* , *6* , *7* , *9* (due 2 a needed pt deduction) , 10 (a 2 pts rd due 2 a pt deduction from Mayweather)
    FJM : *1* , *2* , 8 (due 2 1 pt deduction) ,



    In rd #2 Floyd stepped on Castillo's foot and therefore it was rightfully ruled a slip and not a KD.

    Lederman and shostats gave Castillo rd 5 but I scored it even.

    After rd 6 both Harold and I had it even: He had it 57:57, I had it 58:58
    In rd 8 Draculic deducted 1 pt from Castillo 4 hittin on z break.
    All fight considered, Catillo also threw low blows and Floyd used elbows.
    After rd 9, Draculic should have deducted a pt from Mayweather, but in refrained from doing so.
    So compubox, Lederman and I gave the otherwise (for me) rd 9 2 Castillo.
    In rd #10 Draculic deducted 1 pt from Mayweather for repeated elbows making it a 10:8 rd 4 Castillo.


    I had it 119:118 or 117:114 for Castillo.
    Harold Lederman had it 115:111 Castillo.
    John Kane & Jerry Roth had it 115:111 for Mayweather.
    Anek Honkonkam had it 116:111 for Mayweather.
    Vegas judging.
    Castillo was paid good $ 2 sell his title in Las-Vegas.
    2z boos of z crowd.
    Compubox also had Castillo z winner.
    He was busier and more accurate according 2 it.
    Far busier (more than x2) and slightly more accurate in power punches.
    With Larry Maerchant Floyd made a commercial and gave n Xcuse 4 hurtin hiz shoulder while trainin 4z f8.
    Crowd was repeatedly chanting "Castillo!" during z interview.




    JLC vs FJM #2:
    JLC : *4* , *5* , *7* ,
    FJM : *10*
    Total : 3:1 Castillo (119:117)



    Promoter: Bob Arum (promised JLC a rematch b4 their 1st fight)
    Z Mandalay Bay in casino , Sky Sports , referee Joe Cortez (PR) , Floyd (Filthy Rich Productions yet again)
    Judges:
    Ken Morita (JAP) , Larry O'Connell (ENG) , Daniel Van De Weile (BEL)

    Glen McCrory (Sky Sports) gave Floyd rd 9 which was very close.

    Glen McCrory scored it 116:112 for Mayweather.


    I do intend 2 watch his fights vs DLH, Hatton and Judah.







    When I watched his fight vs Cotto I was surprised at how clearly and convincingly he beat Cotto.

    Mosley was shot 2 death when they fought and I did not score it when I watched it.

    Marquez was n obvious mismatch which I may watch in z future more due 2 a deserved interest in Marquez, but Mayweatherwise it was a meaningless fight.
     
  2. bballchump11

    bballchump11 2011 Poster of the Year Full Member

    63,185
    16
    Oct 27, 2010
    don't forget Mayweather vs Reggie Sanders. He definitely lost that one. And he should have been DQ'd vs Judah.
    Then Oscar won also
     
  3. Kid Cincinnati

    Kid Cincinnati GOOD BOY NATION Full Member

    5,636
    7
    Sep 9, 2010
    So what your saying is, Floyd is way better than Ali.
     
  4. ISPEAKUMTROOTH

    ISPEAKUMTROOTH Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,517
    4
    Jul 2, 2011
    The only fight i have an issue in his wins is Castillo 1,but that is a wee bit false too as Floyd banked the early to mid rounds and Castillo came on with unbelievable work rate but a rounds a round,no matter how many punches you land in others.
    Watched DLH yesterday when i was lifting and how anyone can give it to Oscar is beyond me and the margin gets wider every time i watch it.Will watch the Maidana 1 today but although he did well cant give it to him,ever.
     
  5. panchman69

    panchman69 Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,917
    1,665
    Sep 10, 2012
  6. Robney

    Robney ᴻᴼ ᴸᴼᴻᴳᴲᴿ ᴲ۷ᴵᴸ Full Member

    91,174
    25,461
    Jan 18, 2010
    Seriously, I don't like Floydweather and he lost Castillo I, but this is bull.
    you can make a case for Maidana I being a draw, but that's about it.
     
  7. LondonRingRules

    LondonRingRules Boxing Junkie Full Member

    10,524
    1,118
    Nov 5, 2011
    This thread is hilarious. I had all of them fights scored 120-120 draws, no clear winner in any of the rounds.
     
  8. Mr_Harry

    Mr_Harry Guest

    Floyd lost to castillio it was a clear loss.
     
  9. salmos

    salmos New Member Full Member

    74
    33
    Apr 20, 2013
    IMO a clear loss would amount to losing 8 or 9 rounds or at the very least losing 7 rounds very clearly.

    I've scored the fight 3 different times. I think Floyd clearly won rounds 1-5. And every time I've found 2 rounds to give him in the rest of the fight.

    Not a clear loss in any way.
     
  10. Mr_Harry

    Mr_Harry Guest

    I get what you mean but I had Castillo winning comfortably
     
  11. CST80

    CST80 Liminal Space Autochthon Staff Member

    223,417
    199,715
    Nov 23, 2013
    I had Castillo winning, and the 1st Maidana match a draw. Oscar did really good but I only gave him 5 rounds. And Floyd pretty much beat everybody else.
     
  12. Collie

    Collie Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,638
    8
    Jun 16, 2012
    Im glad I clicked into this thread. I actually lol'd at 120:119 for Maidana Mayweather 2. Good trolling!
     
  13. Badbot

    Badbot I Am An Actual Pro. Full Member

    36,487
    20,151
    Apr 17, 2011
    :lol::lol:
     
  14. lordlosh

    lordlosh Boxing Addict Full Member

    6,696
    6,073
    Jun 4, 2014
    Floyd was gifted against Castillo, that was a roberry, even Mayweather not believe he won the match. Not to mention Castillo was throwing more and landing a lot more. Esp. in power punches department when he land arround 110-1120 more power punches then Floyd and hes accuracy was better ....
    If judges not helping him, that zero would not excist from long, long time.
    I hope not see same travesty at may 2.
     
  15. Nonito Smoak

    Nonito Smoak Ioka>Lomo, sorry my dudes Full Member

    53,089
    6,658
    Sep 8, 2010
    Any true boxing fan knows which fights Mayweather lost...

    L UD12 Castillo I (117-109 at closest for Floyd)
    DRAW Castillo II (duh)
    L DQ1 Gatti (KD'd him while he wasn't looking, DQ)
    L DQ10 Judah (trainer entered ring, DQ)
    L SD12 Oscar (117-111)
    NO CONTEST Hatton (with neutral ref Hatton wins easy, UD, so doesn't qualify)
    L TKO2 Mosley (ref should have stopped it, TKO2)
    L DQ4 Ortiz (KD'd him while he wasn't looking, DQ)
    DRAW Cotto (duh)
    L UD12 Maidana I (118-109; 10-8 1st)
    L DQ8 Maidana II (8th round at latest for this putrid should-have-been DQ)

    Any true boxing fan knows...

    Floyd Mayweather Jr.
    36-8-2-1