There's serious arguments for both sides imo. Joe has been more dominant in his career than Pac in stretches.
the ******'s are trying to make a fight between the dogs and the cats so they will leave them alone, typical tmt strategy. when the division gets hot, retire and let them destroy each other then win on points on the last man standing. hehehe. genius monkeys. just don't claim fame when you fight dirty.
Pacquiao - He might be the B/E in some of the divisions he was in Cal - Best ever in just 1 division for me. So, Pacman.
Joe even ranks higher than Mayweather. Joe beat an ATG for a championship on foreign soil. Mayweather NEVER fought outside the United States. Calzaghe never lost a fight. Mayweather lost two. Judges got it wrong. Mayweather cherrypicks. Calzaghe doesn't.
I hate Mayweather, but his resume is 10× better than Calzaghes. Joe's two best wins came over geriatrics.
Calzaghe never dominated or impressed against a prime or near prime all time great like Pac did a number of times, just like Floyd he has failed light up when the pressure was on.