Clarification Needed On Joe Calzaghe's ATG Ranking...

Try not even top 100 realistically.

 

nobody cares

 

Name 3.

 

One of the most rated boxers of all time :nod

 

:good Finally someone gets it. Floyd lost to JLC the first time and Maidana as well.

 

Well it's a much greater accomplishment than being known as a prolific sheep shagger which is what most Welsh do best. :rasta

 

Ahead of Floyd atsch

 

Even thats not given! Jimmy Wilde is considered best fighter from Wales.

 

Definitely behind floyd and manny. He's top 100 though.

 

for starters joe isn't even welsh by birth, he is English, raised English as a minor, and that is the main reason why mentioning him above true welsh champions is so insulting.

why should I name 3? one is enough, Wilde, and that one topples the statement made. Joe is not the best in wales, and not anywhere near a list in England.

That said, you have asked for answer, however inappropriate your question may be, so I will answer your incorrect question as best as I can - Jones and Welsh were both excellent dominant champions that can be considered above joe, and that warrants three.


I will concede that joe is "arguably" between 3 and 6 in the tiny, massively underpopulated province of wales. but in England, hes not even top 100.

 

Name 100.

 

This is pretty much how I see it.

 

Scoop?

 

are you serious, plenty of brit fighters won undisputed titles and defended them. all of them for starters are greater than joes unwanted wbo run.

 

Yeah I have him ahead of Floyd Mayweather Sr too