Myp4p top 10

Absolutely. Even more so if Canelo beat Carl Froch twice in his next 2 fights at 168.

:smoke

 

you seem a knowledable guy. What do you think of my list?

 

Why thank you. I think it is quite good except Ward is too high for my liking and Cotto should be replaced by Uchiyama or Estrada. Other than that, quite an agreeable effort.

:smoke

 

Thanks. I admit i have a soft spot for cotto but until he loses i think he is good for a place. the fact u say ward is too high says to me you think he deserves a place on the list which in turn validates my point about top fighter going back on the list once they return from hiatus

 

Check my list, he's on there :nod

 

I would heavily favor Canelo against Smigga :nod So should you :nod

:smoke

If Canelo went on to beat Froch after losing to Ward in his next two SMW fights (Like JMM beat Pac in his next 2 after losing to Floyd) the win would age even better. :nod A win over Smigga does not age, it only rots.

 

How come you have him in and not Amnat? :huh

 

He made a mistake in addressing his comment to you, Rummy. He said he was talking to the knowledgeable poster and then did not protest when I replied. Little more than a clerical error. :yep

 

i just didnt want to be rude. I asked rum but you replied. I was happy to here your opinions on my list

 

But could Canelo beat Smigga? :think

 

No, it was an honest mistake and you don't want to hurt Rummy's feelings. It's okay. We all know what happened but we can let Rummy have this one.

Oh, and I don't have Cotto on mine, I thought you meant Ward

 

My bad i misread your list. Have edited. Out of interest in your opinion could ggg,kov or stevenson beat ward. Ggg at 168 other 2 at 175